In 2019, which are the best cordless drills you can buy?
I have been avoiding this question for a while, having last updated this guide nearly three years ago. Every year, there are new models. Sometimes there are big updates, other times, minor changes.
For many users, a cordless drill will be their first and even most-used cordless power tool, or power tool in general. Because of this, there is an overwhelming variety of options out there.
Advertisement
The same question comes in regularly – I’m looking to buy a cordless drill/driver, which should I buy?
Generally, there are few cordless drills that you shouldn’t buy. But, if you’re looking for something in particular, there are specific models that might suit your needs and preferences a little better.
The following roundup reflects my opinions, based on the very many cordless drills I have used or tested. It’s not an exhaustive list, but a summary of my current recommendations, for the cordless drills I’d buy or recommend right now to satisfy different criteria.
Do you agree with the following cordless drill recommendation? Disagree? Please let us know in a comment!
Best Cordless Drill Overall: Dewalt DCD991 3-Speed Brushless Drill (20V Max)
Is Dewalt’s DCD991 cordless drill/driver the most powerful? The most technologically advanced? The absolute best of the best? The most compact heavy duty drill? No. But it’s my favorite heavy duty drill.
Advertisement
The Dewalt DCD991 cordless drill is powerful, with enough oomph to handle any holes I’ve asked it to drill. It is highly capable, and without being unwieldy.
This model was released 3 years ago, and was at the time described as being faster, stronger, better.
While heavier than compact cordless drills, the brushless DCD991 is still comfortable to use. The grip has a good feel, the drill is easily controlled, and it’s simply a pleasure to operate.
Quite frankly, you can’t go wrong with this drill. If you need more than the Dewalt DCD991 cordless drill/driver can provide, let us know and we’ll try to steer you in the right directions.
If you need a hammer drill, for occasional drilling into masonry materials, look for the Dewalt DCD996.
- 820 UWO max power
- 3-speed gearbox
- 0-450/0-1300/0-2000 RPM
- 7.9″ length
- Weighs 4.6 lbs
What’s special about the DCD991 is its 3 speed settings, with the middle range allowing for intermediate speeds that fall between max power and max speed ranges.
Buy Now(DCD991 via Amazon)
Buy Now(DCD991 drill + impact driver combo via Acme Tools)
2nd Best 18V Cordless Drill: Milwaukee M18 Fuel Hammer Drill 2804
Here’s our review of the latest Milwaukee M18 Fuel brushless hammer drill. I really like this drill, and how compact it is for a tool of its power and capabilities. But, while this Milwaukee is called the most powerful drill in the industry, I still find myself preferring the Dewalt.
If you find yourself needing the absolute maximum amount of torque in an 18V-sized tool, the latest Milwaukee Fuel brushless model should definitely hold your attention.
In truth, you cannot go wrong with either model, as they are both heavy hitters and top performers.
The Milwaukee M18 Fuel hammer drill bests Dewalt’s top cordless drills on paper, and is a fantastic choice. It’s not my favorite at the moment, not because it lacks in any department, but because I like the Dewalt’s unique 3 speed ranges. Milwaukee also does offer a One-Key model that allows for user customizations.
Overall, it’s fair to say that this is a very, very close choice for title of best 18V/20V Max cordless drill/driver. In all frankness, it is likely the best cordless drill you can buy today, but my slightly higher personal affinity for the Dewalt influences how I’d rank the two against each other.
If Dewalt’s top cordless drill’s 3 speed ranges doesn’t do anything for you, and you’re not impressed by Milwaukee’s advantages when it comes to power or size, then deciding between the two could come down to whether there are any current money-saving promotions that will appeal to you.
- 1200 in-lbs max torque
- 0-550/0-2000 RPM
- 6.9″ length
- Weighs 3.2 lbs (tool only)
There have been some reports of excessive heating, but we couldn’t replicate it during initial or follow-up testing. It’s not something to be alarmed over, in my opinion, but something to be aware of.
Buy Now(M18 Fuel hammer drill and impact driver Packout bundle via Acme Tools)
The best “kit” option to get this drill is currently as part of an M18 Fuel + Packout bundle.
Best Compact 18V Cordless Drill: Milwaukee M18 2801 Compact Brushless Drill
Milwaukee’s M18 cordless drill/driver offerings changed again last year, including their compact brushless drill/driver, 2801.
The Milwaukee 2801 cordless drill features a brushless motor, good mid-range specs, and best of all, it’s affordably priced. Last holiday season, the 1-battery kit was on sale for $99. We might not see the same promo for Father’s Day, but maybe we’ll see something similar. I’d be willing to bet that we’ll see a similar deal next holiday season.
A few years ago, buying a brushless cordless drill meant spending a lot of money for the latest and greatest tech. Now, you can get brushless motor efficiency benefits in a more compact tool like this one.
This is another case where Milwaukee and Dewalt are nearly tied for first place, but I’d give the title to Milwaukee based on their better affordability. While Dewalt does also have seasonal promo brushless drill kits for $99, they’re not quite evenly matched against the Milwaukee.
- 500 in-lbs max torque
- 0-500/0-1800 RPM
- 6.5″ length
- Weighs 2.5 lbs (tool only)
Buy Now(via Acme Tools)
The Dewalt Atomic compact series cordless drill might be a contender for the next update of this roundup guide. It was not available for testing as of the time of this roundup.
2nd Best Compact 18V Cordless Drill: Dewalt DCD791 Compact Brushless Drill (20V Max)
The only downside about the Dewalt DCD791 cordless drill is that it costs more than Milwaukee’s compact brushless model.
It’s a little longer than the Milwaukee, but also has a bump-up in max speed specs.
- 460 UWO max power
- 0-550/0-2000 RPM
- 6.9″ length
- Weighs 3.4 lbs
I really like the DCD791, giving it title as “best compact cordless drill” the last time I did a drill/driver recommendations post like this one. The ergonomics on this drill are perfect, and it is highly capable, especially for its size.
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Read More About the Dewalt DCD791 20V Max Compact Brushless Drill
Best 12V-Class Cordless Drill: Bosch PS32 Brushless Drill
There are many decent 12V-class cordless drills, but the Bosch PS32 continues to be my favorite. It’s compact, as powerful as one needs in a tool this size, and I especially like how well-tuned the adjustable clutch is for when working with smaller fasteners.
I can’t quite describe what makes this such a good 12V-class drill/driver. It’s not just a smaller and less powerful cordless drill compared to 18V models, it seems to be optimized for its size, if that makes sense. It’s wonderful to use on projects, such as cabinetry installations, where you need control rather than brute power.
- 180 in-lbs max torque
- 0-400/0-1300 RPM
- 6.5″ length
- Weighs 2 lbs
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Read Also: Why Bosch’s 12V Brushless Drill and Driver are PERFECT
Best Budget 18V Cordless Drill: Ridgid R861162SB Brushless Drill
The Ridgid 18V R86116 brushless hammer drill is one of the best cordless drill/driver kits you can find at the $99 price point.
It is powerful, but not bulky, although I personally disagree with how Ridgid describes it as a compact brushless drill. Compact cordless drills aren’t typically bundled with auxiliary handles.
I bought a copy of this cordless drill last holiday season, to compare against other brands’ $99 cordless drill kit options, and the Ridgid’s performance blew me away.
If you want to buy a highly capable cordless drill, but don’t quite care about the cordless platform behind it, this looks to be the best budget choice out there. You get a brushless drill with what looks to be class-leading specs, and it’s kitted with 2 batteries.
The Ridgid R861162SB kit is still available for $99 at the time of this posting. Among all of the cordless drills I’ve tested, and even among those I’m merely familiar with, this Ridgid kit offers the greatest bang for the buck.
If you need a more capable cordless drill kit than this one, be prepared to double your budget.
Read the Review: Ridgid Brushless Compact Hammer Drill Kit
- 750 in-lbs max torque
- 0-500/0-2000 RPM
- 7.5″ length
- Weighs 5.72 lbs with battery
Buy Now(via Home Depot)
2nd Best Budget Cordless Drill: Craftsman V20 CMCD700C1 Drill
The Craftsman CMCD700C1 cordless drill kit is a cheap drill that delivers a proportional level of performance. It’s regularly $79 with a charger and battery, but can go on sale for $69 during holiday season promos.
It’s slower and less powerful than all of the other 18V or 20V Max cordless drills discussed here, and is not as compact. This Craftsman V20 cordless drill can’t handle heavy duty applications, and stalls on 3/4″ holes if you’re too aggressive with feed pressure.
But, that’s all to be expected, as this is an entry-level cordless drill. Compared to the other DIY brands’ entry-priced options out there, the CMCD700 is a respectably average performer. I like the potential that the Craftsman V20 cordless power tool platform holds, and I also like the slide-style battery form factor over the stem-style batteries of Ryobi, Craftsman’s top competitor.
See Also: The Best Cordless Power Tool Brand for DIYers? 2019 Edition
- 280 UWO
- 0-350/0-1500 RPM
- 8-1/4″ length
- Weighs 2.7 lbs without battery
If you’re looking for a cordless drill at minimal investment, this is a fair performer from a trustworthy brand.
Reader’s Choice
Do you agree with these cordless drill recommendations? Disagree? Is there a different model you’d recommend for any of these categories?
Are there any particular drills you want to nominate for the next update of this guide?
Advertisement
jason gloekler
having had all 4 of the top recommendations, I think you are spot on. I prefer Dewalt, but if you have the Milwaukee equivalent, then youll be doing just fine. Never used the rigid, bosch, or craftsman but all seem solid if you just need a drill, or like you said, dont care about the platform behind it.
Flotsam
I agree but and maybe this is just confirmation bias, but i have DeWalt 20v brushless , then M12 tools for around the house and also that Ridgid hammer drill.
But this is truly an impossible task. With the myriad of fine tools out there how to choose. There has to be a degree of buying into a battery platform. Most people don’t like having a myriad of tool brands (unlike me).
Joseph
I am on the Milwaukee m18, m12, Ridgid 18v, Dewalt 20v, 40v, and the Bosch 12v battery systems. For a guy with a shop, rather than a pro maximizing truck space there is little downside to multiple battery systems.
Being on multiple systems means you can always buy a tool that comes out that you need and you don’t have to wait for Milwaukee to come out with a mower, Dewalt to come out with a Flexiclick or Bosch to expand their 12v line.
Another nice thing about multiple battery systems is you can very often find power tools in the clearance sections of the big box stores and equip a garage for 1/2 the price of being married to one brand.
To start out there is no noticeable difference between any of the 18v systems, besides junk like black and decker and harbor freight. A person getting their first drill to fix a fence or build a deck in his backyard will not notice a difference at all. Pick a color you like and buy the best deal you can find.
Frank D
My newest Ridgid drill, as pictured, brakes so hard upon releasing the trigger, that it loosens the chuck and drops the drill bit every second or third lag bolt hole I pre-drill … have to retighten after every use???
Mosh
It might similar to the DeWalt dcd995 which you have to tighten the Chuck than you counter turn it once to hear a click than it’s tight.
Frank D
When it comes to which drill to buy, the reply should be: do you foresee yourself doing DIY / repairs, inside or outside, that will possibly require other battery operated tools?
Which may point to using one platform over another.
Perhaps a combo kit is better value buy in that scenario.
Perhaps the platform with the most individual tool options, for inside and outside use is the smartest option …
… rather than buying the best “ rated “ drill.
James
I’d be interested in a breakdown of drills (and tools in general) to avoid.
Stuart
It’s hard to look at things in that way without knowing what one’s budget, needs, or wants are.
For someone looking at a daily-use tool, a 5-3/8″ cordless circular saw would be a poor choice. But for someone looking for a tool that will be used seldomly, the latest and greatest brushless 7-1/4″ saw might not be the best choice either.
Generally, I avoid direct-to-Amazon brands. They’re not established names, and I don’t know if I would or could trust them yet.
Steve
“Generally, I avoid direct-to-Amazon brands. They’re not established names, and I don’t know if I would or could trust them yet.”
+1
Chris
Whatever Walmart sells
Nick
Surfing Amazon, I found a wide range of Kobalt tools. Maybe they’re taking over from Lowes
Stuart
https://toolguyd.com/kobalt-tools-store-on-amazon/
Lowes/Kobalt haven’t commented about the matter yet.
Luke T.
Kobalt is getting phased out of Lowe’s stores in favor of craftsman stuff. I heard all the kobalt hand tools were on super close out pricing this weekend.
Doug
Having three speeds is nice, I agree, but I’ve never found a use for DeWalt’s middle gear. I always use either low or high. For what drill bits do you use the 1300 rpm speed?
Best cordless drill/driver in my opinion is the three speed Metabo. 550, 2000, and 3800 rpm. Loads of torque and more compact than the new Milwaukee when you remove the chuck and use the quick bit adapter, as I do 95% of the time.
Stuart
Bosch Daredevil bits, for example, have a recommended top speed of 1500 RPM.
That middle setting comes in handy once you get used to it. It’s not necessary, but nice to have.
Corey
I’d place the Makita subcompact drill/driver (non hd) as an honorable mention for compact, and I honestly expected the gen 3 fuel to take top, but I had forgotten the the heat reports. I did get my hands on a buddy’s after I passed on buying them, and they’re impressive. I did find it annoying how small it was when it bound and how difficult it made it to control it. Lot more shoulder planting to break through drilling metal. Still very nice though. Thanks for another great year, Stu!
Gordon
I’m curious as to why the Makita was left off the list as well. Particularly the XPH11Z. It has more power and is smaller than the Bosch 12v.
Stuart
I debated that, as the XFD11 and XPH11 are good (even great) compact drills, but I also find them to be cramped.
I have to draw the line somewhere, or these posts get out of control. Once there are a few more reader recommendations, I can add popular models to the “readers’ choices” section.
D
Bosch DDS183 compact 18V drill. The lightest and most compact of all the compact drills. It also includes kickback protection and an electronic clutch. Newer models have Bluetooth connectivity to adjust settings. It should have been on this list instead of the Milwaukee. I also have a DCD791; it’s fantastic but I prefer the Bosch. It even has a more comfortable grip than the Dewalt (and not many do).
Stephen
I got the DDS183 right when it came out. It has served me well, although the trigger on two different models has gone out once in a blue moon. The anti-kickback programming has saved my wrists a few times.
Agree on the compact size and ergonomics. The all metal chuck is nice. I can’t wait to pair it with one of the new Core 4.0 Ah batteries, which are the same size as the previous gen 1.5 Ah slim packs.
D
Yeah those 4.0ah batteries look great
Davidaa1
I think it might be a good idea to point out, that for a 12v drill Milwaukee has a vast lineup. So if someone is starting out, it might be worth it to invest in that platform. In the same vein for a budget 18v I would go for Ryobi. They’re readily available and cheap and some of their stuff is great, eg. Airstrike etc, or something you know you use often.
Russ
Good article. I’m looking forward to a Best Impact Driver version using currently available tools.
Stephen
12V: Milwaukee Fuel
18V: Dewalt
That Guy
M18 FUEL SURGE
Corey Moore
I don’t see an oil impulse counting as an impact, or coming close to topping the category if it is considered. The performance isn’t there-small to medium fasteners per manufacturers, will not hold a candle to top of the line ¼” impacts in power or speed. Great tools, but not close to replacing regular impacts in heavy duty.
Sam
I want to hear what people have to say to this
Joey Gresock
I work commercial/industrial setting as an electrician. Install and service work. I use a surge every single day and not only do I think hydraulic drivers are the future I believe they are a better tool now. Yes 90% of my fasteners are small to medium fasteners but so is 90% of what everyone else is driving on the same jobs no matter the trade. The fact of the matter is there are such a few number of people that actually need the massive power of the top of the line impact. Big companies have convinced so many you need the most power possible. False I need just the right amount of power. After having to replace countless panel cover screws because people need the strongest impactors you’d prolly see my point to. (well aware that if they knew how to use the tool properly would minimize the problem) And let me tell you after using the surge for over a year I’ll prolly never go back to a traditional style anvil impact driver. Especially after hearing how quiet and smooth a hydraulic driver is. I’m not saying that there isn’t need for powerful 1/4″ impacts just that not that many people need them and just because they’re “more powerful” doesn’t make them the “best” impactor. My 2 cents from an electrician.
Corey Moore
I’m an industrial electrician myself, and when building or fabricating anything on site, the smallest socket I’ll typically use anything is going to be a 9/16. I’ve messed with a surge a younger guy brought out, and it’s very cool but it kept wanting to tap itself out before I needed it to. Personally I own 3/8 and 1/2″ dedicated impacts because I got real tired of snapping/losing 1/4″ to drive adapters. I’ve been eyeballing the Makita impulse since it’s in one of my platforms, but after using the surge I’m still going to reach for my 3/8 regular impact for anything like unistrut or above.
dave9
Yes, what I want out of an impact driver is mostly small, and inexpensive. A clutch would be nice, which is why I end up using my cordless drill for many things where it fits, but otherwise before my cordless impact were to reach its limits, I’d have already felt an impact wrench was the more appropriate tool, except again, if the impact driver’s small size allows it to fit where nothing else will, or for very low torque a cordless ratchet instead. Impact driver is my least used of these 4 options, and I paid the least for it. It’s great to have budget tool options in the market without having to settle for direct to amazon generic junk.
JoeM
I disagree with “Second Best” Cordless Drill on that first Milwaukee. I think it deserves equal footing with the DeWALT counterpart. “Alternate Choice” perhaps, instead of 2nd.
Plus, I prefer Hammerdrills as a whole. Better to have it, and not need it, than need it, and not have it. Premium AND Compact versions.
Chris
I’m surprised you didn’t mention Kobalt. I think they have some wicked cordless tools for the price.
Stuart
Yes, but how long until Lowes decides to abandon the Kobalt 24V platform in favor of something else, again? Kobalt 24V Max tools are good, but best compete against DIYer brands, and among DIYer brands, others’ platforms are broader and more guaranteed to be supported over time. I like Kobalt, but there are other drills that I’d sooner expand the discussion with over theirs.
Chris
Fair point. I really hope Lowe’s doesn’t completely kill off kobalt. Or at least there should be a backup retailer to take over kobalt if they do end up getting dropped. But I bet we would notice a significant quality drop of that happened.
Flotsam
This is the first i’ve heard about Kobalt power tools going away. I’ve heard about the strong consolidation of the hand tools due to Craftsman, but not the Kobalt power tool line.
ktash
If you look at the prices, the Craftsman 20 volt tools are competing directly with Kobalt sometimes cheaper. The Craftsman 6 1/2″ bare tool saw is $69, the Kobalt is $129. They have a lot of Craftsman 20v, not just hand tools. Plus it looked like some clearancing of the lesser used tools last time I was in there.
Stuart
There are rumors of a new Kobalt cordless power tool line, but so far it’s just hearsay. My comment was not based on that, it was based on recent years’ history, where Kobalt changed from 18V to 20V Max, and then abandoned the line for the new 24V Max platform. Today, Kobalt 18V and 20V Max users have no options for support or expansion. Kobalt is unpredictable, and there’s no guarantee for the longevity of the 24V max platform.
Frank D
People with Ridgid’s 24v power tools were left in the cold for a while as well … though years later ridgid finally offered 18v tools in exchange.
ktash
Yeah, I think Lowe’s is shooting itself in the foot on this one. I got the Kobalt 24 v saw and it is great, with better depth of cut than most others in its class. They never seemed to promote it much after the first days. Is this a cash flow problem, that they couldn’t beef up the line. Ryobi has stability and lots of tools, innovations, and lots of promos so you are often thinking about their brand when you go into Home Depot. Not so much Lowe’s and Kobalt.
Lowe’s may not be making good decisions and that’s a shame. Too heavily invested in Craftsman. If they decrease or drop their other brands and Craftsman isn’t your thing, they’ve lost business to Home Depot with HD’s variety. Or even to Menards, though they have too many second or third tier brands.
Dave
Best drill for someone who has to be asking what kind of drill to buy? Anything from a major manufacturer with a proven history of supporting their platform – you won’t go wrong with Milwaukee, DeWalt, Makita, Ridgid, or even down-market brands like Ryobi or Porter Cable.
For the entry level user I think the better question to ask is what other projects they might take on somewhere down the line. Make your drill choice based on the other tools in a manufacturer’s platform you might see yourself using someday.
If you only want a drill and nothing but a drill, I’d recommend shopping primarily based on price, still limiting my choices to well-established brands. In a situation where a drill is literally the only power tool you ever see yourself needing, nearly all of the modern offerings will be solid enough to get the job done.
Frank D
Completely agree.
Somebody looking to buy a drill, needs to consider future tool use and battery plus tool platform ( and thus brand ) more so than “ best drill for the money based on specs, etc.
One can actually go as far as saying, and I have done so in the past, if you need a tool and are only going to use it a couple times a year, skip the batteries, buy corded. Battery power retention is a lot better than what it was, but for the very casual user … it is one more thing to just be dead when you go to use it.
My late uncle had a bunch of corded and battery operated tools, any brand, any tool, … all the battery built-in or external pack units were junk … all the corded ones worked.
Ken
No Makita love?
PETE
Never! & Thank goodness! lol
Matt
I agree with whomever said Kobalt. For the price, it doesn’t get better
Frank D
Except Kobalt stuff is being clearanced out, so how wise of an investment is it, when a buyer starts looking for another tool on the same platform? Or needs another battery in a couple years?
Matt
I seen where the hand tools are being phased out in favor of Craftsman. But I have sources who claim the Kobalt line will continue to grow and that some new releases are not that far out.
Some recent releases include a 24v 7 1/4″ miter, a shop vac, a 6ah battery and a shop fan. With more to come.
Kobalt isn’t marketed like the big guys. It’s releases are slipped onto the shelves BUT that doesn’t take away from their quality. This article is about Drills and the Kobalt 24v hammer drill is a good buy. I believe it’s better than any Craftsman (which also is only a developing line). Better than any Ryobi and could go toe to toe with the Ridgid listed here. It’s robust, durable, and fast.
As far as the Kobalt line…..The one handed recip saw keeps pace with the m18 hackzall and costs less. The 6 1/2″ circ saw, with a good blade attached, can cross and rip all day and is lighter than a lot of other saws out there. The battery’s last and are readily available in 1.5, 2, 4, 5 and 6 amp hrs. The impact, though slower than most packs a ton of torque, 3 speeds and has a finishing mode which I use daily. They have lighting options, OPE, Sanders, a grinder and a core line up that will continue to provide the user with affordable pro-grade tools. Neither Chervon or Lowe’s is putting the kibash on 24v tools. This is truth. If you need a source I can provide several. The kobalt hand tools are done. That’s it
ktash
When I got my Makita subcompact drill and driver, I tried some other brands at home depot for ergonomics and Makita won by a mile. I love this drill, plenty of power for the small size. While they may feel cramped for some, it depends on your hands and arms. To me they are just right. They get into spaces where other 18v would not. Since I’ve made a lot of cabinets/furniture with them, this counts for a lot. Though I sometimes use my Bosch ps32 or multihead it always feels clunky compared to the sleek Makita. Plus, buying into a platform, the Makita has the right tools for what I do.
Ergonomics counts a lot unless you are just going to be using it for short periods occasionally, like hanging curtain rods or pictures. So, picking up different models can help a person decide. I say this because when I bought my first drill, a Ryobi corded, I mainly looked at price plus a reliable brand.
Aaron
I own m12,m18, Ryobi 18v, Ridgid 12v and kobalt40v, and at work I stock mostly DeWalt and a few Porter Cable. Those Makita subcompact drills offer something that I think is pretty special: a compact lightweight tool for most jobs that also is compatible with a huge line of both power tools and OPE. They feel great in the hand an I wouldn’t be afraid to carry them around all day.
Steven
As a reader of course the chances of agreement will be low. Its your opinion against all readers. Im fine with your assessment, your allowed your opinion.
There are alot of tools out there to rate and review without bias.
Do you use them all day at work?
Do you play with tools on the side?
Whatever it is, you need to rationally balance what works best for you….opinions are like askholes, everyones got one
Stacey
I think it really depends on the type of user. I’m definitely not a professional and am more of a reluctant DIY husband that only fixes stuff when the “Honey do” list gets out of hand. With that said, I much prefer good tools that are reasonably priced and especially prefer tool systems with lots of tools. Ryobi fits the bill perfectly for my 18v and 40v needs. I don’t need many 12v tools, so Hitachi fits the bill there. Both brands are solid for my occasional usage.
Renato
Love the Makita sub compact! Also think the XPH07 is a better drill than 1st and 2bd albeit on the heavy side. Absolute best…..the new Metabo 3 speed hammer drill.
The What?
Good call on the Dewalt dcd991. I’ve also had mine for 3 years and it’s a great tool. I’ve put it through hell and it just doesn’t seem to want to die. Still works just like the day I bought it. Very well made and balanced for all day use. But a question like that is completely loaded and there is no right or wrong answer of who is better than who. If you give a definitive answer, you’re setting yourself up. I would have replied what are going to be using it for, how often are you going to use it, what are your expectations, and how much money do you want to spend on it. Whether diy or professional, you’re not going to spend more than $175 for the bare tool. Kits are priced accordingly based on need. And based on their answer, I would make a list of suggestions in no particular order without recommending one over the other. If they ask which one is the best then I would tell them to go find out for themselves.
The What?
I saw someone mention oil impulse impact drivers. There’s a video by Ave where he breaks down a ridgid oil impulse and goes into detail about how it will inevitably fail. I don’t know if they’re all manufactured in a similar fashion but you may want to check it out. And I’m certainly not saying it’s a good or bad tool.
Stuart
All tools wear over time, and so the question is whether the benefits over the lifetime of the tool are worth it.
Thom
As far as the Craftsman drills go I think you would be better off with the brushless US made CMCD721B which generally goes on sale for $70 or $80 around Christmas and Father’s Day
John Fal
Yea the craftsman brushless are good, the regular ones lack a bit.
Stuart
True, but for the price of a kit, the Craftsman brushless drill faces strong competition from Dewalt, Milwaukee, Makita, and other brands’ promo offerings.
Andrew
Seems like an okay list but the only thing I’m confused about is how isn’t Milwaukee’s 12v drill the best on the list/market. Nothing can compete with it and makes the Bosch look like a toy.
Stuart
I like the Bosch better.
If you only have one drill, the M12 Fuel is king. If you want a pair of drills, with an 18V for medium and heavy duty tasks, and 12V for lighter and higher precision tasks, the Bosch offers greater control.
With 12V-class drills, I feel that modest specs and an optimized feel are more important than sheer power.
With both tools at my immediate disposal, I prefer the Bosch. I do enjoy using the M12 Fuel in tasks where I would be just as willingly to reach for a compact 18V drill. The M12 is a fantastic and highly recommended drill. But which would I rather use? The Bosch.
My guides like this one are subjective recommendations, which is why I emphasize that reader input is especially welcome. My opinions do fluctuate over time as well. The then-current model of M12 Fuel drill was my top choice in 2015 (https://toolguyd.com/best-cordless-drills-2015-edition/#best-12V-overall), but that changed in 2016, and I continue to favor the Bosch most of the time. M12 Fuel was also my top choice in 2014. https://toolguyd.com/best-cordless-drills-2014-edition/ . Spring 2013? Also M12 Fuel https://toolguyd.com/best-cordless-drills-032013/ .
PHILIP JOHN
I have both top premium drills. I too find my self liking dewalt better.
Both have strange side handles… if dewalt had an aluminum one it would be perfect.
Dewalt size is more balanced when both use a big battery.
Dewalt hammer mode at half inch kicks ass.
Dewalt clutch when reducing the settings also automatically reduces speed… a nice touch. Clutch is amazing and well used for so much power control.
Milwaukee clutch is also hammer switch. It’s nice but I find for this kind of power its compact size is harder to get use too . It’s better than the gen 1.
D
Earlier I mentioned the Bosch DDS183, but I’d like to add another vote for the subcompact Makita. I previously owned one and it was fantastic.
Steve
I find myself wanting a smaller battery and/or a compact M18 drill/driver as all I have are 5AH batteries. Looking around I see the packout compact brushless drill and impact bundle for $200 with 2 2AH batteries. Are there better deals and/or packages I should be looking at for something to reduce weight when working overhead?
Stuart
If all you want is a compact brushless drill, it might be worth waiting to see what Milwaukee will have available for Father’s Day promos. That Packout combo is a great kit, if you can use the impact driver and the non-compact battery too. It was recently on sale for $150 as a deal of the day, but $199 is a good seasonal price, it’s just not as low as it could go.
Steve F
Actually the impact is more important to me but both are useful. I keep thinking about the m12 fuel as well. Most of what I’m doing is overhead electrical, running conduit and fixtures etc. Trying to juggle a full size drill and impact while working overhead with all the other electrical tools on my belt is making me grumpy ?. Thanks for the help Stuart, this is by far my favorite tool site!
Nathan
Nice update and you’ll never make everyone happy. Perhaps a reader’s choice post might be an interesting result.
Meanwhile I don’t own but continue to eyeball the 3 sp dewalt for many of the reasons you said. I like the idea of having the middle ground speed even though I might not use it much. and it being a gear ratio not powering down the brushless is important.
On the impulse vs other impact drivers – I sort of agree. One of the reason I love my Dewalt 3 sp impact driver. I do a good bit of my work on setting 2 because I don’t need all the torque and speed and it’s easier to control that way.
Matt J
It’s so hard to do a test like this because the lines between Pro and DIY and DIY versus budget are so blurred at this point, it’s very difficult to delineate categories. Add in seasonal pricing changes, and it’s nearly impossible.
That said, I agree with almost all of your recommendations, outside of possibly the 12V Bosch. I’ll admit from the outset that I have not used it, so my opinion is already diminishing in value, but I just have a hard time spending $130 on a tool kit when there is not that much else out there that I can use the batteries on, and where there is so little difference between the abilities of the other drills in the class. Bosch is better than some (DeWalt) in their 12V tool diversity, but they haven’t come out with anything really new for a while.
For that reason, for me, I’d have to go with something in the Milwaukee M12 line for the 12V category if for no other reason than they are the only company that has shown me a true commitment to continuing to develop a 12V tool line, and I do not find the differences in 12V drill features all that significant in terms of recommending one model over another. To me, a 12 Volt drill is intended for light duty, high precision drilling and fastening, and its primary benefit is small size and light weight. To me, nearly all drills in the 12V class achieve satisfactory results in this respect, and the differentiating factor is what else is available in the line.
I am a different reader than most in that, all other things equal (price, performance, etc.) I will usually go for a new platform of batteries rather than sticking to what I already have when buying a new tool combo kit, because I look at the platform diversity as a way to allow myself the least restriction to get a tool that fits my needs/budget for whatever I’m working on in the future. If I need, let’s say, an oscillating multi-tool for a relatively limited use, the fact that I have DeWalt, Ryobi, and M12 and M18 batteries already on hand allows me to choose the best fit for the price rather than feeling like I have no choice rather than having to go with a particular brand.
CountyCork
Bosch 12v is decently well rounded as far as what they currently offer. https://www.boschtools.com/us/en/boschtools-ocs/12v-max-cordless-power-tools-37932-c/
Construction Carl
So many DIY guys. This forum really should just look at Ryobi, Craftsmen v20, Kobalt, Ridgid for those pics. Sounds like 90% electricians, really they only need 12v tools, same with HVAC guys. Plumbers are going to Milwaukee and builders are into Dewalt.
…..You buy into a brand for its line of tools. Very surprised no pc Harbor Freight drills were on the list.
Matt
I see a lot of comments on the Makita Sub compact and am surprised. It’s a nice, light weight option but when it comes to preference, there are many other drills I would place before that.
I think Metabo offers some of the best drills you can purchase. The SB 18 LTX 18 is perhaps the nicest drill I have used. Where else will out find a drill with 3800rpm and 1300 in lb of torque? But this is really all about preference.
Panasonic. Hilti. Fein. All have really precise, easily controlled 2-4 speed drills. Which brings to mind a new category for you Stuart, “the best, most unheard of drill” which could easily go to the Fein ASCM 12 C. The best 12v drill out there although it’s sized similar to the m18 compact. The Fein packs 2500 rpms, 360 in lbs of torque and comes kitted with 2.5ah Batts.
I think the Bosch 12v defines what a true 12v drill should be and is a joy to use. Its my go to drill for electrical work. To me the m12 fuel is a great option but, for me, it’s too heavy and bulky for compact work. It’s more of a replacement for an 18v drill not a supplement. I also like the Makita 12v Brushless drill as I have other tools in that line.
I also enjoy the Ridgid Octane, the Craftsman Brushless non hammer drill and Bosch’s compact Brushless hammer drill.
There are just too many to talk about
Stuart
Construction Carl, aka Framer Joe, do you actually have a specific model to recommend?
Corey Moore
You’ve a limited scope of what electrician can entail. My bet is your around residential stuff.
glenn
The six electricians that subcontract to us all use 18v tools. They do a mix of residential and commercial.
We do aircon installs and use 18v and 12v. 12v as some tools are only available in 12v.
OldDominionDIYer
Both of these drills are excellent choices, as you mentioned Stuart it really boils down to personal preference since the One Key version allows for RPM limiting albeit a bit more complex than the 3-way switch it does gives the user that functionality. The big thing for me is the ergonomics which I know is subjective and not really defendable but is so very important. I was recently doing a job where we were using my 2804 and my co-workers DC991 and what I noticed right away was the positioning of the reverse switch on the DeWalt is way further forward than the Milwaukee’s. I mean so much so that I had to change my grip just to reach it. I have XL hands (10″ span) so it’s not likely to be just an issue for me, we compared the two side by side and the DeWalt’s switch is about 3/4 of an inch further forward (when you align the backs of the grips of both units) I was surprised they were so much different. The other thing I noticed right away is that the DeWalt is bigger in almost every way. Clearly one of the important dimensions is the length where the Milwaukee’s shorter overall length may save you a trip to the tool box to hunt down your right angle adapter but even the barrel diameter is bigger and thus adding to its overall bulkiness and weight. Suffice it to say these are excellent options and that’s why I always recommend that potential first time buyers actually visit a local store so they can handle each one for themselves because like it or not ergonomics matter especially in a tool that is bound to get a lot of use.
Nathan
you know a few of you mention the speeds going the other way and I have to admit I wonder why you don’t see a cordless drill that runs faster like 3000 or so.
Aimed more at metal work. IE like a ______ cordless 3 speed that run 0-800, 0-1800, 0-3000. I know there is the one. but I could see others making that specifically for the high speed metal drilling. would be nice to have the option.
Or maybe even one that only does 0-2000, and 0-4000. whatever. Don’t know it would have a large market but I think there would be some.
Oleg k
Really? Dewalt is your best pick?
The compact and full-sized hammer drills made by Milwaukee are more powerful and much better made than whatever dewalt has to offer, the impact drivers are precise and drive the screws without misfires or stripping them and, if you want to talk about advanced technology, OneKey is LIGHT YEARS ahead of Tool Connect, not that anyone ever uses it… In addition, Dewalt uses cheaper, less robust parts, such as brushless motors, to build their tools, their sales strategy is a gimmick and their sales tactics are confusion and misrepresentation of facts, that’s why their power tools have to come with a fine print on the boxes with a lesson in physics about nominal vs. actual voltages and an explanation on why their 60v (54v actual) flexvolt tool battery says 6ah but is only 2ah, right next to the “USA made” logo and an explanation that all the parts and the cardboard the box is made of was actually made in China… Seriously, the only thing the United States laborers do is put screws in, or less…
Milwaukee also offers a much better warranty and their customer service and repair departments are much, much better, not even talking about the fact that they only have one high-performance tool like and all their 18v batteries and tools are interchangeable and do not result in any significant losses of power?
I don’t believe that someone as knowledgeable as you are can honestly pick Dewalt over Milwaukee, I mean, you claim to be a professional contractor and constantly imply that you’re also a man of integrity, can you please explain to me how and why Dewalt drills are better and how come, for years now, you willingly and openly ignore their shortcomings, claiming they’re great? Is it really because you’re blind to how crappy their tools really are? Because that would make your authority nonexistent, I really hope you wrote this post for the sake of your Amazon commission and Acmetool kickbacks or whatever dewalt promised you in exchange for your soul.
All the best.
Stuart
You’re arguing about One-Key vs. Tool Connect, 20V Max vs. M18, and FlexVolt 2.0Ah vs. 6.0Ah nomenclature, but did you actually USE the drills discussed in the post? If so, what didn’t you like about it?
With the way affiliate links work, I hope you realize that if I recommend something and am so far off-base that someone returns the tool, we get zero affiliate revenue. There’s also no brand weighting. Buy Dewalt, Milwaukee, Makita, etc., and it still supports us the same.
If you’re a ToolGuyd regular, you’d also know that I NEVER claim to be a professional contractor, because I’m not.
With cordless drills, I yo-yo sometimes with my preferences. Not day to day, but sometimes from season to season. The M18 Fuel Gen 2 was always at-reach. But sometime last summer, the Dewalt became my go-to for heavier tasks. The Milwaukee Gen 3 is a fantastic drill, but these days I prefer the Dewalt.
There are no elaborate schemes, back-end deals, agendas, or what-not. I’m insulted that you would suggest it, more so that I’m shocked that you don’t like my recommendations partially based on One-Key vs. Tool Connect and FlexVolt amp-hour marketing conventions.
Have you tried the drill and found any shortcomings? Because it just sounds like you don’t like Dewalt, and you’re not happy that I don’t share your criticisms unrelated to the drills being discussed. If so, that’s fine, but don’t insult me by saying I have questionable authority because I’m honest about which drills I like best.
The DCD991 and DCD791 cordless drills are fantastic tools. M18 Fuel and compact brushless are fantastic drills.
And regarding marketing, it was technically Milwaukee’s M12 lineup that set a precedent for rounding-up cordless power tool battery sizes.
Brian
Carpenters prefer Makita
Plumbers prefer Milwaukee
Do-it-all’s like DeWalt
I ride or die with Makita
Mike Beauchamp
If store brands are in the mix,let’s include Kobalt drills.They are some tough customers.I would put my $100 Kobalt KDD524B03 against the Dewalt DCD991 any day and I have. I loved my Dewalt but battery would not last but 30 minutes tops.I laid down 660 deck screws in one session before my battery gave out.The feel of the Kobalt is stout and solid.To me,not so much with Dewalt.Don’t get me wrong,Dewalt is tops but I find price comes with the name.All companies cut corners!
Matthew Byers
The 28 volt Milwaukee drill will never be matched .The power and torque it has is unbelievable .I have used this drill for years literally abusing it only for it to take the abuse .Its a shame Milwaukee has thrown it to the side for the 18 volt fuel its a good drill but there is no comparison to M 28 volt drill .
brock hutchins
ive used milwaukee dewalt and makita and for impact drivers the dewalt and milwaukee are gutless compared to makita. i personally run makita becuse thats what i started with but if i had to change my combi drill i would get the milwaukee FPD2-502X becuse of the fact that it has got near impact driver power.
Warren
What about the Ryobi line of tools?
Stuart
https://toolguyd.com/best-cordless-power-tool-brand-diy-2019/
Sam Conseal
Ive been in construction for 30 plus years and ive used them all .
Makita is the best cordless out there .
We use them all day every day and they keep going .
Ergonomically there isnt a better tool .
Sam Conseal
Note
Look at the design changes over the years, they all copied Makita.
Anton
Working for an HVAC company for the past 20 years l have seen my co workers go thru 3 or more Dewalt 20V cordless drills.
Dewalt make a damn good drill, l have used makita, Milwaukee and Dewalt, my last new drill was in 2015 l went to Lowes and bought a Milwaukee 18V drill but it was for home use, it was the combo set and the flashlight went out the 1st week.
I took it back for a refund when l seen the same set at our supply house, it was a commercial drill with the bigger lithium battery so l bought it there.
Remember when buying drill at Lowes or HD that it’s not about price, it’s for what you need.
Last year l bought a Bosch cordless, Lowes had a nice one for $149 but it came with the 2.0 battery.
I went online and found a nice set, the cordless and hammer drill, it came with the 4.0 battery but you could upgrade to the 6.0 battery for $30 more.
I got to say after using Mikita, Milwaukee and Dewalt l like the Bosch much better, l will put my 18V Bosch up against any 20V Dewalt.
I love it, my coworkers love it too, a few went out and bought their own Bosch and the others say when it’s time for a new drill they will switch from Dewalt to Bosch.
For our work, mostly residential and light commercial it is all we need.