Someone recently asked for multi-bit screwdriver recommendations. This is both an easy and difficult question to answer.
It’s easy because there are plenty of multi-bit screwdrivers worth recommending. The difficult part is that there are so many multi-bit screwdrivers worth recommending. Each one is slightly different, whether in shape, style, ergonomics, or the type of bits it’s compatible with.
What works for me or you might not work well for someone else.
Advertisement
Generally, I prefer multi-bit screwdrivers that work with standard 1-inch screwdriver bits. There are exceptions, of course. Sometimes a design is just so convenient and superior that it’s worth dealing with proprietary or hard to find replacement bits.
Keep in mind that we’re only focusing on multi-bit screwdrivers here, which are differentiated from bit holders. Multi-bit screwdrivers have on-board bit storage, making them somewhat self-contained screwdrivers without the need for loose bits and pieces, bit holders don’t.
PB Swiss Insider
The PB Swiss Insider is one of the first tools I ever reviewed here on ToolGuyd. It’s also one of my most favorite EDC tools, screwdrivers, and even one of my most favorite tools, period.
Mine isn’t yellow, it’s red, but right now only the newer colors are available on Amazon with free shipping. You can find PB Swiss tools through a couple of independent USA distributors, but the last I checked shipping is only free if you order from Amazon, and that only applies to Amazon-fulfilled tools.
The PB Swiss Insider is compact and built with a strong magnetic bit holder. The bit cartridge holds 10 precision bits, and screws into the Insider’s handle for secure storage.
Advertisement
There are other versions of the Insider, but they cost quite a bit more. I’ve lusted after some of those models for a while, but with my Insider 1 still going strong, I can’t justify an upgrade just yet.
I bought mine over 7 years ago. Should anything ever happen to my PB Swiss Insider, I’d buy another one without hesitation, with a blue, yellow, or black-colored handle.
Although the price seems steep, much of the cost is tied to the extremely high quality screwdriver bits.
Price: $40
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Wera Kraftform Kompakt 25
The Wera Kraftform Kompakt 25 multi-bit screwdriver is an unusual beast. Its bit cartridge is in the middle of the tool, and is accessed via spring-loaded release hatch.
Then there’s the extendable and even removable rapidaptor locking bit holder. Rapidaptor-equipped bit holding screwdrivers are among the best locking screwdrivers I’ve found. This one can be locked in two places (recessed and extended), and can also be used in a completely separate tool, such as a cordless drill.
Let’s not forget the ergonomic shape of the handle. It’s a tad wide and bulky, but not so much as to be a deal-breaker.
Here’s a somewhat recent discussion of the Wera Kraftform Kompakt 25.
It’s priced at around $30-35, which isn’t too bad if you consider how much just the Rapidaptor bit holder costs separately – $21 via Amazon.
This model comes with a carrying pouch, for belt storage.
Price: $31.50
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Irwin 9-in-1
I bought one of these Irwin multi-bit screwdrivers years ago (at least 7), and it’s continued to serve me well for casual and unexpected fastener loosening or tightening needs.
It’s a removable shaft screwdriver, as are several of the recommendations here, which means the entire shaft is itself a double-ended tool. The bits are double-ended as well, with ball detents for retention.
With this kind of multi-bit screwdriver, you’ll probably replace the whole thing when a few bits are worn or lost, rather than trying to hunt down replacement bits.
This isn’t the best multi-bit screwdriver of its kind, but it works well, is easy to spot in a mess of tools or in a household junk drawer, and is nicely priced at under $10.
Price: $9
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Klein 11-in-1
I’ve used Klein’s X-in-1 multi-bit screwdrivers, and they offer good quality at reasonable price points. I think I have just one 11-in-1 and a couple of more 6-in-1’s, but like them all equally.
With the 11-in-1, or 10-in-1. you get the most nut driver and screwdriver bit sizes, but the 5-in-1 or 6-in-1 can sometimes be found at appreciably lower pricing.
Klein’s multi-bit drivers aren’t my go-to ones anymore, but I always make sure that I can find at least one in my toolbox.
If I lost all of my multi-bit screwdrivers, this is one of the few replacement options I would gravitate to without having to think about it.
Price: $14
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Stanley All-in-One
I bought a couple of Stanley all-in-one screwdrivers, and they’re quite decent for the money. This one is currently a little over $4 at Amazon, although it’s an add-on item meaning it has to be purchased as part of a larger order.
I had one with a more elaborate handle design, and the shaft rusted. Stanley offered to replace it, but I didn’t want to spend the shipping cost to send it back even for a free replacement. I guess I shouldn’t have left it exposed in the car trunk for 2 years.
Because this one is so inexpensive, I don’t feel bad about tossing it into a junk drawer, random strategic places around the workshop or home, or in my car’s glovebox.
Just because it’s cheap doesn’t mean it’s cheap. I like these drivers, and feel that I get much more value and quality than I’m paying for. Shh, nobody tell this to Stanley or they might raise the price.
If you buy multiple multi-bit screwdrivers, say 4 at a time, this is the one to buy.
Price: $4.50 and an “add-on item”
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Picquic SixPac
Picquic offers a couple of different multi-bit screwdrivers,with this one being the SixPac Plus. There’s also the Multique, which looks similar but is sized for smaller hands and more compact stowage needs.
It ships with 7 bits, and storage space for 6, plus one more if you keep a bit in the bit holder.
And you really do need to keep a bit in the bit holder, since that 7th bit is needed to push other screwdriver bits out of the handle storage compartments.
These are nice and handy screwdrivers to keep around.
The last I checked, Picquic SixPac screwdriver handles were made in Canada, and the bits overseas – I believe Taiwan.
Price: $15
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Lutx 15-in-1
I tried out the Lutz 15-in-1 ratcheting screwdriver after a reader recommendation, and although I haven’t a clue as to where mine is, it recently popped into my mind when visiting a local hardware store.
Question: Do You Buy Tools & Supplies at Big Box Home Centers or Independent Stores?
It lacks the bells and whistles of higher end ratcheting screwdrivers, and works with double-ended bits that have centered ball detents, but that’s easily forgivable.
If I could only spend under $15 on a ratcheting multi-bit screwdriver, this would be at or near the top of my shortlist.
Bit storage is elegant, but the handle is a little shorter than I’d like to see on a full-size screwdriver. On the upside, the Lutz ratcheting screwdriver is more compact than many other ratcheting and multi-bit screwdrivers.
Price: $14.50
Buy Now(via Amazon)
PB Swiss T-Handle Universal Bit Holder
PB Swiss’s 455 M T-handle universal bit holder doesn’t quite fit in with the other tools discussed here, but I didn’t want there to be “only” 13 recommendations. One more was needed.
But, it does fit in somewhat, as it does offer built-in bit storage and works with standard 1/4″ hex screwdriver bits.
There are lots of things to love about the PB Swiss Tools T-handle screwdriver, such as its solid construction, free-spinning sleeve for rapid turning, and thumbscrew-accessible bit storage compartment.
Although somewhat large, it’s also somewhat flat, negating most storage considerations.
With the T-handle configuration, you can exert more torque than you could with most if not all of the multi-bit screwdrivers shown here.
Price: $43
Buy Now(via Count on Tools)
Felo Bit-Boy
Felo’s multi-bit screwdrivers of this style are harder to find these days, but it looks like Carbide Processors has these Felo 373 Bit-Boy screwdrivers, and with multiple bit kit options.
As with the Wera, these have a somewhat chunky handle geometry, which you might or might not like. I like mine, but don’t know if I’d buy it again. It’s not as featured as the Wera, but it can be found for less than half the price, depending on your choice of bit loadout.
Price: $14 to $18
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Buy Now(via Carbide Processors)
Megapro “Automotive” Ratcheting
My first-ever ToolGuyd review was of a Megapro 15-in-1 hex bit screwdriver. In one of those images you can see my Irwin and Klein multi-bit screwdrivers.
I didn’t quite like the handle, which was large and a little slippery.
When Channellock came out with a Megapro-made ratcheting screwdriver, I was quite pleased with the grippy and comfortable handle. That screwdriver works with Megapro’s double-ended bits, which are easily replaced, at least as far as proprietary or special bits go.
This Megapro “automotive” screwdriver has the same comfortable handle and excellent ratcheting mechanism, but works with standard 1/4″ hex bits.
It’s a little pricey, but Megapro’s quality and performance are worth it. This could be the first and last ratcheting screwdriver you ever need.
Price: $36
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Milwaukee Compact Ratcheting Bit Driver
Milwaukee’s compact stubby ratcheting screwdriver, which I reviewed last year, is well-built, and inexpensive.
There are more things to break on a ratcheting screwdriver, but this one seems to be up to rough and tough use. It’s not the best ratcheting screwdriver or mini multi-bit driver I’ve used, but it possesses a good balance between size, comfort, functionality, quality, and cost.
Price: $15
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Stanley Stubby Bit Driver
At just a penny over $5, this might be the cheapest ratcheting screwdriver that I’ve used, and I have yet to throw it to the ground in a fit of rage.
It’s not as good as any of the other multi-bit screwdrivers mentioned here, but it’s half-decent and will cost you less than a meal at your favorite fast food joint.
Price: $5 and an “add-on item”
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Wiha Stubby Multi-Bit Driver
I have yet to try Wiha’s stubby multi-bit screwdrivers, but they’ve been on my wishlist for a long time now. They’re teeny, with storage for 6 bits in their compact and stubby handles.
There are 3 versions available on Amazon – one with Phillips and slotted bits, another [more expensive] one with fractional hex bits, and a third model comes with Phillips, slotted, and Pozidriv bits.
I’m a big fan of Wiha’s SoftFinish screwdriver handles, and use my stubby one-piece screwdrivers quite often.
Price: $21-28
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Apollo Mr. 7-Hands
This is another multi-bit screwdriver that I have not yet tried, but numerous readers have recommended the Mr. 7-Hands screwdriver over the years. It has a unique folding arm design, but it looks like the bits aren’t user replaceable.
Price: $12-15
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Your Favorite Multi-Bit Screwdriver?
The next one I’ll probably try is this Husky multi-bit screwdriver, which is $5 at the local Home Depot. I can’t seem to find the one I thought I left in my car’s glove box or trunk, and so a replacement is in order. For $5, I won’t mind leaving this in the car until I need it.
I would consider buying another Stanley All-in-One that’s mentioned above, but I think that the hard handle on this one might be more durable than the Stanley’s soft grip.
Do you have a favorite multi-bit screwdriver?
And do you have different favorites for different uses, as I do?
Although I love my PB Swiss Insider screwdriver dearly, I keep usually reserve it for EDC and on-the-go fastening needs. I’ll use it for home projects sometimes too. But I’m not going to buy one for every glove box, kitchen junk drawer, tool kit, or other locations where a less expensive multi-bit driver would suffice.
Advertisement
Hepdog
+1 for PicQuic – have owned several and bought 10+ as holiday gifts
-1 for Klein – have one and never use it.
Want: PBSwiss
Mikey
The true beauty of the PicQuik is that you can’t lose the bits. You can’t get a bit out without putting in a replacement. It’s genius. I just discovered today that some A-hole at work stole mine from my tool bag. NOT happy…
Dan
It has to be the older version of the sears autoloading screwdriver. No need to fumble with pulling bits and replacing them, just extend the handle and select a bit. Jams were very rare and usually fixed with a couple twists and taps, nothing that would delay getting a job done. It also sounded kind of like a pump action shotgun, always fun 🙂
Norm
Ideal 35-988 9-in-1 Ratch-a-Nut Screwdriver for me. Use it daily.
I would have liked the Ideal 35-688 21-in-1 Twist-A-Nut Screwdriver, but it got wet, and bits rusted.
I really would like one like Megapro 151SS 15-In-1 Stainless Steel Driver bits, in either of the screwdrivers.
Also any of the multi-bit screwdrivers, the shaft strips out too easily if I put too much torque on them for nut driving purposes.
Sleepy
+1 for the Picquic in general. I especially like the Dash7 that uses common 2″ power bits. It’s a little less ergonomic but you have access to a wider range of bits and less guilt if you damage one.
Brian V
I bought the Klein and have been very disappointed. The bits fit so loosely that I find them stuck in the screw or I’m on my knees looking for them on the floor or the ground. I can’t recommend it.
Michael
Sorry to hear that. I use mine daily under hard use with no problems.
Gilbert
Same here. One of my go to drivers Klein 11-IN-1…. Just very convenient set-up & good price point. I usually carry 2 in my tool bag. I’ve also been carrying the stubby Phillips/flat head combo-Klein. I will say this, I think their fit ‘n’ finish quality has been slipping a little…. For what it’s worth.
Jared
My Klein 11-in-1 does the same thing. Bits get stuck in the screw then they fall out when you don’t want it it. I’m surprised I havent lost any yet.
I am very happy with my Wera Kraftform Kompakt 25. That is my goto multi-screw driver.
Brendan
My Klein has quite a bit of play in the bits as well. I also find it takes quite a bit of time to find the bit I need because you can’t see all of them. My choice now is the Piquick. Its cheap, the bits are secured well in the handle, fairly well made, and the bits can be used in a drill or impact driver if you choose to.
jay
the bits fall right out of all the Klien mulit bit screwdrivers I have owned. large and tech. Would never recommend the klien. I worked for years in construction
Raymond Carpenter
I bought a whole set of kleins. All the ends are rounded off. Sorry to say I am using an ols Craftsman when I need a good grip.
Charlie Stopczynski
My TWO favorites are the TWO 6-in-1’s received. One from a grand opening of a nearby Lowes store, and another from a promo at Highland Woodworking some years ago in nearby Atlanta. Can’t beat the price.
PS those low priced 6 in 1’s are great. If you’re a woodturner, you can turn the plastic handle off and turn a nice wood handle, press fit, and present to someone as an inexpensive custom gift.
Tom
Generally prefer old fashioned dedicated drivers, but the Stanleys are great value for the “junk drawer”. Have one on each floor of the house in a convenient spot and find they do a fine job for all those quick needs that come up in any house.
Lee
+1 Stanley All-in-One
Very handy, but make sure you check every single piece is on there before you leave the job site.
+1 Picquic but it’s for super 8 plus & Teeny Turner (Super handy for those sudden electronic sensor fix)
http://www.homedepot.ca/product/super-8-plus-multi-bit-screwdriver/936474
http://www.homedepot.ca/product/teeny-turner-microbit-screwdriver/981000
Mike
I swear I could start a blog dedicated just to this topic. I will try my best to be concise.
Stubby: Wiha is indeed awesome, if available. However, for most uses, electrical especially, the following is a personal locally available favorite(actually I use the 32561):
https://toolguyd.com/klein-6-in-1-stubby-screwdriver/
For serious electrical work:
http://www.amazon.com/Wiha-28393-Insulated-Precision-Screwdriver/dp/B00U24VHWO/
http://www.licensedelectrician.com/Store/ID/21-in-1_Twist-a-Nut.htm
Ideal isn’t as well known as some more common brands, but some of their tools are ‘ideal’ in terms of quality and usefulness, sometimes value too.
Wiha 28393-Stuart, to you I heartily suggest getting one for review. Excellent tool, especially as an ‘EDC’, for those who prefer/need 1000v insulation.
General X-in-one: so many choices, Felo/Wera/Wiha always decent or better, Klein is a good go-to, Greenlee/Ideal/Irwin/Milwaukee are OK too. I personally find the handle comfy on this: Lenox 23932
Two closing points: 1) PB Swiss: eh, ur, uhm they are too…expensive. Not overpriced per se, just too spendy. Like Stuart, I too REALLY like PB Swiss all round, but the prices! If a decent Wera or Wiha or Proto driver is say twice as much as a ‘normal but not garbage’ driver, then PB Swiss is twice as much as that! My theory is this: PB Swiss, the 1/4’hex one inch OAL bits ESPECIALLY, are not really any “better” than the top offerings of Felo, Wiha, Wera(and Festool too-so no Festool boo hoo please). PB Swiss is however made is Switzerland, so presumably the workers earn like one or two Euros worth of compensation a MINUTE. Even Germany, and Czech Rep. especially, don’t have such formidable wages. Now, PB Swiss does seem to sell a sophisticated product with great QC compared to AVERAGE Wiha or Felo or Witte, although not necessarily any better in terms of durability and fitment. But consider this example:
http://www.amazon.com/Wiha-53398-Screwdriver-Phillips-MicroFinish/dp/B001ATOSNK/—–REVIEW! REVIEW! REVIEW!(and then send them to me!)
The above are the BEST all-round drivers ever. As good as Hazet, Gedore, Snap-On(etc), Irazola, and PB Swiss. Yet reasonably priced and kind of available. The only thing is personal handle preferences: it's true PB Swiss does sort of have hand sex with the user. But Wiha shaped handles are pretty neutral. I don't hear as much complaining about Wiha handles as say Wera, Felo, or even Witte/Matco.
Chapter, I mean -point- 2)Obviously you are just an amateur, Stuart; someone who doesn't know a cabinet tip from an e-torx. Cuz EVERYBODY knows SNAP-ON is ALWAYS, AUTOMATICALLY, and FOREVER the best!!! Cuz why else would they cost so much?
ps, you already posted the best driving tool: http://www.amazon.com/Metabo-SB18LTX-BL-2-Inch-Brushless/dp/B00L47AMRE/?tag=toolguyd-20
pps, as many ToolGuyd readers undoubtedly agree, there's truly only one "best" tool; the one that works. By no means my go-to, no driver ever saved my bacon like the one on my EDC Leatherman Wave. That little guy has been by my side every single day for a decade. Still looks and works great too.
Mike
and for those looking for top-quality insert bits: APEX is where to go. Truly good tools, INSANE variety. Just prepare for lots of product number sorting. A link to the Phillips section:
http://www.apexfasteners.com/fasteners/apex-fastener-tools/bits/phillips-bits/1-4-hex-insert-bits
And it gets my goat that in the UK Stanley/Fatmax sells a bunch a cool stuff that we can’t buy here in the states.
Eh, one day, one day…we’ll all use Torx drive.
Tom
I have the Wera and it is great. I don’t love that you really need two hands to open it up to get bits (the release mechanism is really tight), but it is a superb tool. The case is nice, but not really something that is useful to me. I always think about just throwing it out but wonder whether I would regret it someday.
It’s worth noting that you can get the Wera at Sears.com, which is usually pretty easy to buy with points and coupons.
Matt
I am pretty negative on my Wera, for one basic reason – a knucklehead borrowed it and hammered on the handle end. Yes, incredibly stupid.
But it mangled the plastic and the mechanism. Just too fragile a tool for any real environment.
I have the Lutz, and have had about 4 over the past 30 years. It has just the right bits, including some square ones, to be the best junk drawer screwdriver around.
But the Wera is definitely pretty. It just stays in the bag.
Drew M
Does anyone make a driver with a bit gripper like most 1/4″ hex impact drivers have? I’m always annoyed when the short bits pull off the magnet in my drivers. (then fall and disappear)
Mike
Stanley 69-189 Ratcheting Multi-Bit Screwdriver
Wera 05003263004 Kraftform 98/4/1
Wera Kraftform 816 RA Bitholding Ratcheting Screwdriver
Wera 05051024002 Kraftform Kompakt 25
http://www.amazon.com/Wera-05051024002-Kraftform-Bitholding-Screwdriver/dp/B001HSNHM2/?tag=toolguyd-20
Stuart
The Wera screwdriver I discussed above has an active locking bit holder.
Drew M
I should have mentioned that I’ve been moving away from using the little 1″? long bits and using the ‘power’ bits almost exclusively since I like how my impact drivers grip them and they won’t pull out.
I couldn’t find any photos that show if the Wera tool comes with these ‘power’ bits or if they’re the short type with some kind of special gripping mechanism on the driver.
Jerry
I have the Wera, and it uses the short 1 inch bits. The holder locks them in very securely, yet releases them easily. One of the best bit holders I ever used. One feature I really like about he Wera shown above is that the bit holder is attached to a shank that removes from the handle, that has the grooved hex drive that works in an impact driver. I have no idea if it is rated for impact use, but I have yet to have any problems doing so.
SteveR
They’re pretty pricey (about $65.00 now), but I really like my Snap-on SSDMR4BO ratcheting screwdriver. It seems bullet-proof, and for the money, it should be (I think I paid about $40-45 at the time). It has a stainless shaft and a magnetic bit holder. I’ve had it forever; it came with four bits; I added a case and a bunch of other bits (Torx security, Robertson square, etc.) over the years. It’s my go-to for jobs around the house. It has never jammed, unlike the Megapro Compact ratcheting screwdriver I have around for standby service. Both of these have high tooth counts, which is just as important as on a socket wrench.
Another good one, for confined spaces, is the Blue Point BTWOS, with a 25 degree offset handle and magnetic bit holder. It looks like a POS at first glance, but has a reversing lever and angled handle to keep your hand above the work surface. It also has a high tooth count in the mechanism, and is made in the USA. Blue Point (Snap-on) also offers this with a straight handle and a 25 degree reverse offset handle, should you need them. Sears and several other sellers offer this same hex-bit screwdriver handle for less, so check it out with them.
I do keep Picquic screwdrivers in the trunks of our cars, but have never used them. The handles are a straight barrel shape of hard plastic, so they’re not what you’d call ergonomic. I’d call them utilitarian.
BikerDad
I’m looking for a good precision multi-driver. Any suggestions?
Mike
Define good.
glenn
http://www.wihatools.com/700seri/759_microsets.htm
Allen
I bought the Megapro after your review, and several more for family since.
I have found it to be an excellent tool, very well made.
Tom A.
I have the MegaPro listed above and have used it daily for 5 yrs. Or so now. Excellent sd, never any problems. I also bought the Milwaukee stubby ratcheting listed a few months back and it’s a pretty good little sd and generally keep it in my car and in my pouch when mountain biking. Both have been great so far.
james d
i have the WERA KRAFTFORM KOMPAKT 25 and i love it! best one hands down!! i also own the milwaukeee stubby one and use it all the time in small spaces.The ratcheting comes in handy
fred
Over the years I’ve bought many multi-bit screwdrivers. I can’t say that I’m really a big fan of any – but here’s a list of what I’ve bought over the last few years:
Company Part No. Type COO
GREENLEE 0153-43C 9IN1 SCREWDRIVER TAIWAN
KLEIN 32561 STUBBY MULTI-BIT SCREWDRIVER TAIWAN
KLEIN 32562 STUBBY MULTI-BIT SCREWDRIVER TAIWAN
KLEIN 32477-SEN 10 IN 1 SCREWDRIVER USA
KLEIN 32500-12CS-SEN 11 IN 1 SCREWDRIVER USA
KLEIN 32527 11 IN 1 DRIVER W/VALVE CORE TAIWAN
KLEIN 32559 EXTENDED TIP MULTI-BIT DRIVER TAIWAN
KLEIN 67100 ROTARY TIP (RAPI-DRIV) DRIVER USA
MEGAPRO 211R2C36RD 13 IN 1 RATCHETING SCREWDRIVER CANADA
MILWAUKEE 48-22-2113 11 IN 1 SCREWDRIVER TAIWAN
MILWAUKEE 48-22-2101 10 IN 1 SCREWDRIVER – WITH ECX TAIWAN
MILWAUKEE 48-22-2102 10 IN 1 SCREWDRIVER – WITH ROBERTSON TAIWAN
MILWAUKEE 48-22-2103 10 IN 1 SCREWDRIVER – WITH TORX TAIWAN
MILWAUKEE 48-22-2104 10 IN 1 SCREWDRIVER – WITH SAE HEX TAIWAN
MILWAUKEE 48-22-2106 10 IN 1 SCREWDRIVER – WITH METRIC HEX TAIWAN
PICQUIC 06102 TEENY TURNER – MICROBIT DRIVER CANADA
PICQUIC 91102 STUBBY – MULTI-TIP SCREWDRIVER CANADA
PICQUIC 88100 SIXPAC MULTI-BIT SCREWDRIVER CANADA
Wayne R.
I’m not totally sure, but I believe each of those are reusable.
Michael
I have and use many traditional and multi use drivers . There are no “best” drivers. I do like the 9 in 1 drivers to keep weight and bulk down in all of my specialty bags and cases (electrical, plumbing, HVAC and carpentry). In my shop, I reach for the traditional drivers.
John
Plus one on the Wera Kraftform Kompakt 25, I love mine so much (the make one too with stainless steel bits inside as an alternative as well). The only thing I wish was that it also had the ratchet feature from the Wera Kraftform 816 RA bit holder screw driver. As the Wera Kraftform Kompakt 25 came with a nifty belt pouch, I just keep both together in it for the times I need the ratchet over the length.
I also need to give praise to my Klein Tools 32517 Multi-bit tap tool driver which has 6 different screw taps and 4 drivers built in one tool. in one tapping tool and driver.
tap sizes (6-32, 8-32, 10-32, 10-24, 12-24, 1/4-20)
Screwdriver tips (#1 and #2 Phillips, 3/16” and 1/4” Slotted)
Three Nut Driver sizes (¼”, 5/16” and 3/8”)
That thing is amazing and build like a tank. I can’t tell you how much time it’s saved me having all that on me while doing electrical.
Curtis
Check out the Wera 05073661002. The extension doesn’t slide in to the handle like the Kompakt 25, but is pretty close otherwise.
John
Ah yeah I forgot about that one but yeah it was on my list as an alternative. Trouble with that one as you said it doesn’t retract into the handle like the Kompakt 25 so it makes it a lot less pocketable personally for me. But a good alternative none the less thanks for mentioning it.
Mike
I really do not like the Klein 11-in-1 since production moved to China. Not because of where it’s now made but because of the design changes and quality decline. The rubber in the handle is super soft. It stretches, tears easily, and is constantly weeping a slick oily substance, almost like it is permanently covered in Armor All. It’s no longer bonded to the handle, so it slips and also makes an annoying squishy sensation when gripped. Bits fall out constantly, especially the Robertson ones. Pull those out perfectly straight or you’ll find the bit still stuck in the fastener head every time. Using the driver as a nut driver strips the barrel and adapter in no time. I honestly don’t understand how this thing continues to get such high praise. It isn’t like Klein can’t manufacture high quality drivers overseas. Look at their stubby multibit driver. Made in Taiwan but you’d never know if not for the label. They just choose not to for their 11-in-1.
While maybe not exactly a multibit driver, Klein’s Switchdrive makes an excellent driver if you like the Klein comfort grip handles. Bits lock in rigidly and make it just like a ‘real’ screwdriver. A coworker carries two handles on his pouch with an assortment of 4-6″ bits in an artist’s brush roll. With the two handles he can set up for what he’s doing and rarely have to switch bits, yet doesn’t have to carry around the bulk of all the normal screwdrivers. It’s a pretty slick setup. I don’t know that it’s worth the $50 it costs, but still neat.
Mike
Wow. My 11-in-1 has somewhat poor ball-detent retainers on the ph2/sl and ph1/sl bits. I have a bunch of SD’s so on my Klein11-n-1, the main barrel is from a Milwaukee and the double end 1/4″ hex barrel is from a Klein Heavy Duty. Not sure if it’s HD, but it is painted black, so that’s a huge innovation/improvement, wah-wah.
Because of your comment, I took a look at my stubby(which actually says ‘taiwan’ unlike the 11-n-1) and it seems a tad better. The detail that I noticed most was the location on the 1/4″ hex stock where the ball-retainer is punched in. On both the ph1 and ph2 bits the ball is moved back from the ph and towards the slotted end maybe 1/16-1/8″. Maybe this gives tiny boost towards not pulling the phillips bits out all the time? Maybe the 11-n-1 is COO PRC vs stubby COO Taiwan, both presenting the typical COO quality tier difference?
Only thing I diverge(?) from concerning your post is the handles. All Klein SD’s I’ve ever seen, including bright yellow stamped MADE IN USA, have loose outer vinyl grips, most are shiny/smooth, not really oily in my case though. The new 11-n-1 is similar but duller, and the stubby is grippy rubber, probably not even a vinyl at all. All the ‘good’ cushion(USA-made) SD’s I’ve seen(Cementex, Armstrong, old Stanley, Western-Forge, Williams) have a bright shiny outer grip that does slide and ‘squish’ as well. Imports like Greenlee and Ideal all have varying outer handle textures. I usually turn Witte insulated drivers these days anyway. Felo premium squishy handle insulated are my favorite, but a bit rare.
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B002YNQVPE/
http://www.amazon.com/Knipex-MAXXPRO-Insulated-SLOTTED-9T-653742/dp/B007PB5480/
Wayne R.
The brush roll idea is terrific. I use the Klein 5-in-1’s a lot but also have a single Switchdrive set up for the “other” bits. Now you’ve got me thinking…
Nathan
I’ve probably bought 4 or more of themegapro ratcheting driver shown there.
more for the driver than for the bits. storage is suitable – fairly sturdy but the ratcheting mechanism is nice and clean for as cheap as they are. IE it’s not a snap on or a SK but it’s not that price either.
I’ve given 2 or 3 away to people easily, I know one guy rigged one with all metric hex and a few torx and keeps it on his off road bike.
Seb
Not exactly a multibit, but I keep a Baby Bost stubby ratcheting screwdriver in my case at all time, I bought it on sale for 5€ and it s amazing. Bost was (still is) owned by Facom, so now by Stanley black and decker, their fatmax stubby ratcheting is almost a straight copy of it. I believe you also find it as Stanley expert and I ve seen readied by Wurth
http://www.lutile-bricolage.fr/tournevis-boule-baby-bost-porte-embout-cliquet-3-position-3-embout
On a side note, I m looking for a full size ratcheting screwdriver, bost makes one but I find it a bit too ‘fat’ . Facom makes a multibit ratcheting one but the price is a bit steep, although it comes with 2 bits storage compartment, one with slotted & Phillips and the other with torx ones. Still 55€ is a bit too much. Any recommendations?
Karibu
You have to try and also “listen” to the Facom ratcheting that you refer at,ACL.1A,(if you have not already).
I think that you will never find an luxurious feeling like this,with “hi-fi” clicks from the 45 teeth and so secure bit handling,also magnetic….what else do you need?
426
Reverse gear ratcheting screwdriver , includes extra features, pistol grip + multibit storage + removable shaft .
Bruce
The Klein 11 in 1 has been in my tool box since I replaced a Klein 10 in 1 about 10 years ago. I’ve worn out at least two a year with daily use for each of those 10 years. It’s was the only screw driver I carried in my tool box until last year when I added a stubby Klein. I’ve chucked the bits, the intermediate shanks and the main shank in drills. Used it to hammer electrical lock rings off. I’ve pried open stuck covers. Held open doors. I even threw it at an attacking dog once. When I’ve got an unknown problem, it’s the one that goes in my back pocket. Cheap enough to abuse, good enough for everyday use. I’ve borrowed others from my co-workers. I have no idea how they put up with the crap they carry. 🙂
Nick Marques
I LOVE the Picquic Multique as I do have smaller hands. I also like compact so it doesn’t take up as much room in the tool pouch or bag. I bought several in different colors so that I could put them in different places and remember which belongs where.
The downside? The bits on it are not your typical “electricians” or “contractor” bits, and they are also 3/16″ not 1/4″ standard.
I’m probably going to get a full size Picquic…
But I also am looking at getting Milwaukee 10-in-1, but I wish they had a kit with the handle and ALL of the bits available for it, so I could load it up with those that I needed, and change as needed.
David Funk
Ideal 21 in 1 is on my list
Greg Michaelis
Rolgear Multibit Ratchet Screwdriver.
Jerry
I have the Wera, and love it. The belt holster is OK at best, but allows for carry without a tool belt. Best bit holder I ever used, and it removes from the handle to be able to be used in a power driver.
I like my Picquic for he very same reason. The handle is OK, but it uses standard power driver bits, which are easily replaced, or customized at reasonable cost. A good driver to have in a junk drawer or grab and go box. They also have a similar model made with marine grade Stainless Steel. You can throw it in the trunk of your car, boat tool kit, or wherever, and neither the bits or driver will rust.
Dont have a Lutz, but like the looks of them.
Lastly, don’t forget ChannelLock. They have what looks like a rebranded Megapro ratcheting multi bit driver, sometimes at a better price. If you like the 4 or 6 in one drivers where you reverse the bits and shank, check out their new pro version, with the blue and clear handle. The handle is good but not super great, but the bits on the one I had the pleasure to use were the most precise of any of it’s type I have used, and seemed very strong. This is their USA made one. Their older imported 6 in 1 was decent, but the new USA made one has much better bits.
Lukas
At work I use the Klein. It has the nut drivers which come in handy quite a bit. At home I have a Mega Pro and a couple of the Picquics. They all work very nice for various tasks.
Lukas
The Mega Pro was a splurge. Typically I don’t like spending that much on a multi screwdriver.
Wayne R.
I use the Klein 5-in-1’s a lot. I’ve also got an Ideal version that’s got a wire-nut twister hole in the butt that is sometimes good for pesky wire boxes.
What I avoid: Screwdriver ratchets and 1/4″ bits. Don’t see a need to complicate the simple beauty of a screwdriver by adding a ratchet, and those little bits are way too fiddly and a PITA.
The worst thing about the 5-in-1’s in their “blade thickness” – sometimes I have to go for a normal slim-bladed screwdriver for clearance/length, which sorta offsets the fewer handles/lighter weight goal of the multi, but whatta you gonna do?
John A
I’m surprised no mention of the ivy classic 17073, great ratcheting handle with bits. I use this for general purpose around the house jobs, the sliding collar/magnet is excellent. I also really like my wera kompakt 27ra2sb ratcheting driver with pop up storage (a bit smoother action vs the ivy classic and a more compact bit holder section).
When working strictly on #2 PH the Klein 603-4 is tough to beat for overall fit, feel and balance. I also like the wera 350PH #2 for damaged screws.
Stuart
I don’t think I have seen that Ivy Classic – ever – but I’ll keep my eye out for it. I’m always up to trying out new multi-bit screwdrivers since they’re so handy.
John A
http://www.amazon.com/Classic-17073-Magnetic-Screw-Driver/dp/B0030CWHLA
It has become a go to driver
(probably the only made in China tool I don’t mind).
Chris Fyfe
ATM PB Swiss , some Snap On , and Klein . I also have Wera .
Stuart is responsible for the PB addiction .
Chris
Stuart
Mwahahahaha!
I think it was Maximum PC that turned me onto PB Swiss Tools. There was interchangeable screwdriver set in one of their magazines once.
Chris
Anyone used one of these?
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B010601CGE?psc=1
Can anybody tell me what ‘Double Drive technology’ actually is?
Thanks.
Stuart
https://toolguyd.com/kobalt-double-drive-screwdriver-video-review/
https://toolguyd.com/kobalt-double-drive-screwdriver-set-preview/
https://toolguyd.com/kobalt-double-drive-screwdriver-set/
With one hand on the driver handle and the other on the gear collar, the internal gearing translates handle motions in both directions to screwdriver bit rotation in a single rotation.
Basically, they’re geared for “righty tighty, lefty tighty” or “righty loosey, lefty loosey” operation.
Chris
Thanks for the explanation.
Brian D
The 11-in-1 Milwaukee 5 inch model has worked great for me, especially working with a lot of 5/16″ and 3/8″ screws for metal.
Stacey
I really like this one I got at Harbor Freight: http://www.harborfreight.com/multi-angle-ratcheting-screwdriver-46801.html . It has a smooth ratchet that reverses and locks, nice bit assortment, and a pivoting handle that locks. The thing feels solid and you can even stick a hex key through the handle for extra torque. I’m sure He-man could break it, but it’s taken everything I can throw at it. At $8.50 it’s a steal.
I just picked up one that is almost as good at Northern Tool, it had the same features minus the lock to disable the ratchet. It was German made and $4, just make sure you check it out before you leave because I had to return one that wouldn’t pivot lock. That was a real surprise since the one I found unboxed in the store was solid as a rock. The handle feels really nice, it’s rubber, kind of like a bicycle grip
Stacey
I found a link to the other one on Amazon here http://www.amazon.com/180-Degree-Pivot-Shaft-Ratchet-Screwdriver/dp/B003ZK917A#customerReviews but I would recommend getting it in store and find a good one before you leave.
Stacey
I picked up this swift drive at True Value. The ratcheting is really smooth and it is the fastest non-powered one I’ve used thus far. All three of these I’ve purchased are awesome. Of course that won’t keep me from buying more! 🙂
Stacey
oh here’s the link http://www.truevalue.com/product/Swift-Driver-Dual-Drive-Ratcheting-Screwdriver-29-Pc-Set/41051.uts
Jim Benson
Nice post, I hadn’t ever seen a lot of these. I am surprised that there was only one mention of the Lenox 9-in-1 (product number 23932). I liked the Klein 11-in-1, but the Lenox has one big advantage. The hexagonal insert on either can be removed and chucked in your drill to use as a nutdriver, but the hex piece on the Klein is very thin and easy to ruin this way. The hex piece on the Lenox is quite a bit thicker-walled.
I like the Picqic for similar reasons, if you put the bit in a drill, I’d prefer the longer shaft so the tip is a ways past the chuck. Unfortunately I do not like the bits they use, maybe the most cam-out-prone Phillips I have ever seen.
I got the Apollo as a Christmas gift, you’re going to give that toy an inferiority complex putting it on a page with a bunch of quality tools.
The PB Swiss looks nice except for the price. I don’t think I’d ever order a $43 screwdriver, but sadly I am not sure if I could resist if I saw one in person.
Alan Nash
I have a lot of multi-bit screwdrivers, but my favorite is made by Allway. It is a fiberglass driver with a powerful magnet. The handle holds 3 bits. The handle is apparently electrically insulated up to 2000 volts, but I’ve never tested that.
The original version was orange and black, and is the superior version. It is also available in yellow and black, but the bits are not that great. Fortunately any 3/4″ bit will work.
It is very lightweight and ergonomic. For a long time, it was the screwdriver that I kept in my hip pouch. I was a desktop support technician, and had to do a lot of on site visits. The weight was a nice feature. I still use it at my current job (still a tech, but it’s more of a desk job). Stanley tools apparently makes a version, but I’m not sure how good it is.
The best part is that it is cheap. Amazon sells it for less than $7. The pic shows the orange and black one, but I’m pretty sure you’d get the yellow and black one. Just replace the bits and you are good to go.
http://www.amazon.com/Allway-SD41-Composite-Shockproof-Screwdriver/dp/B000KKR0ZI/
Bob Channell
I use the multi bit screwdrivers for HVAC service quite a lot. I have Greenlee, Milwaukee, Husky, Southwire, etc and a couple of Picquic. I need nut drivers so I usually don’t use the Picquic for that.
The Milwaukee is the best fit, absolutely NO discernable movement in and out of the shaft when in use, and solid lateral feel. Very well made fit. The wire stripper and bending hole is a nice added touch.
The Greenlee 11 in 1 is top notch, but the 6 in 1 has plenty of in and out slop when in use, which is a deal breaker and relegates it to glove box duty. So quality is hit or miss.
Craftsman makes the same screwdriver and it has some in and out movement, but not as much as the Greenlee 6 in 1.
Husky was the big surprise, PERFECT fit, no wiggle, no in and out movement whatsoever. For around half the price of the others, it’s a SUPER deal. Clearly the best of all of them. I do use the Greenlee 11 in 1 some because of the 3/8″ nut driver, but it’s not needed all that often, so the Husky gets lots of use.
I ordered a Picquic with the nut drivers built in, but haven’t received it yet, we’ll see how it works.
For now, Husky is the best, and I’ll pick up a couple more when I stop at HD next time.
Steven
Klein or Craftsman for me
Chris
Didn’t understand why the FULLER 6 in 1 wasn’t on the list. 1/4 and 5/16 nut drivers and flat/ phillips on one bit and #1 and #2 Robertson on the other. Made in Canada, had a problem with the first one and contacted them and they MAILED me a replacement!!
Bill Bradsky
LOL, I love the fact that if I’m looking for a stubby small multi-bit screwdriver with internal storage, I can type this into google and find your review site with like 15+ multibits reviewed. I was just looking for a small compact multi-bit for computer and car stuff. I’m going to try the Stanley 6-in-1 because it looks super small. Thanks.
Camden
Lenox tools 9in1 my favorite I’ve used so far got it at a Menards for 9 bucks it feels great in the hand
Peter Alexander
Great review love your dedication to the world of tools and you obviously know your stuff. All great SD’s here. However, in my opinion you missed the boat. For price, quality, performance, durability, etc. The Buck Brothers Multi SD in Home Depot (orange handle) is bar far the best and most reliable, categorically. I have many all over the place for years so they are always handy. I think at the very least they should have made the list. Thanks for what you do!
Steve
I have a Craftsman auto-loading screwdriver. It has a 6 bit capacity, and all of them are enclosed in the handle, which prevents the chance of losing any of them. In order to swap bits, you pull the working end away from the handle, use the indicator to select the bit you want, and push the working end back towards the handle. It’s also magnetized, which is amazing, and you can customize which bits you have in it (without having to take it all apart), which is what I have done. I put some of my more durable DeWalt bits inside. It’s my in home go to. I was at an Ace Hardware year’s ago, and picked it up because I thought it was an amazing idea, and to this day, I’m glad I made that choice! Although it’s currently not available any more, it looks like they have an upgraded 13 bit auto-loading Screwdriver with an included ratcheting feature, which I found when I was looking for a link to the one I own)… I think I need an upgrade!!!
Steve
You can also remove the bit and use the shank as a 1/4” nut driver.
Paul K
I’ve used the Snap-on Orange handled one pretty much at least every week for the last 24 years, still great. It isn’t innovative in anyway, it’s way behind the times design wise. But it’s got a good tooth count and lasts and lasts. It’s very unfancy, thought it was was a cheapo when I got it heading off to college. 15 years later when I started learning about tools, and about what I had, I asked my Dad if he knew he gave me a $60 screwdriver, he was also surprised, says he has about a half dozen more in a drawer somewhere. Company he worked for is headquartered near Snap-on, we guess he probably got them years ago to give away to customers to advertise SE Wisconsin manufacturing or something. Anyway, story is to illustrate that while it doesn’t look like much, it’s fantastic.
Mitch
KLEIN Hands-down, the best quality out there. One VERY important fact, is that it’s made in USA !!!
William Adams
My favourite is an Elemen’tary No. 1 screwdriver: https://thescrewdriver.co.uk/ — I just wish they made the No. 2 w/ the same Wiha bit holder
Joey
Hello, my post seems to be a bit late.
I had a screwdriver before, it is a multi-bit, but the bits are inside the handle and you only need to twist and pull-out the bits. The bits actually has their own shaft. So it is portable and easy to carry, no shafts sticking out, just the whole handle.
The bits+shaft is non-removable so there is no risk in losing them. It is portable, magnetic, and seems to be carbide-tip. It has a logo at the end of the handle, a red plus-sign on a black background. The body is actually colored black. I think it is a 6-in-1 if I remember it right. The one I bought has 2 cone-shaped bits, I think one for creating a hole on wood and the other is for concrete.
I lost it last 2008. 🙁
The shop from where I bought it is no longer selling it and the salespeople doesn’t seem to remember. I can’t remember the name or brand. I am looking far and wide in the internet searching for this particular screw driver.
Can anyone help me out please. I really loved this tool, very portable and sturdy.
Any help is really appreciated.
Stuart
That’s a tough one. So you lost the hole-starting bit?
Can you find any current multi-bit screwdrivers with similar features? I like a good puzzle, and hope we can help you! Unfortunately, there’s no guarantee that it’s still made or available to purchase. But, with more clues maybe someone here can identify it for you.
Joey
Thanks Stuart for the reply.
It looks something like this: https://images.homedepot-static.com/productImages/a9d79054-34ef-4f21-822a-ba981fd78bf8/svn/milwaukee-multi-bit-screwdrivers-48-22-2322-64_1000.jpg
Except that there is no metal shaft at the other end. I hope I can attach an edited picture to my post.
The whole screwdriver is only the handle. From the rounded bottom to that black cap thing with arrows on it. No metal shaft to place the bits on.
The bits are also similar, but instead of you pulling them out and placing one at the shaft, they stay inside the handle. You just need to twist the end (the black thing with arrows in it) then you can pull them out at the end, then twist the black thing again to lock.
There is no way you can lose the bits, they stay inside the handle. You just need to pull them out to use then lock it in place. The bits are “built-in”.
The bits have gray tips (seems to be carbide tips) and they are magnetic.
Hope my description helps.
Thanks again!
Joey
This is how the bits (with shaft) looks like. Might be carbide-tipped, and they are magnetic.
https://www.garagechief.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/best-screwdriver-set-990×547.jpg
Joey
The bits are non-removable. They are somewhat built-in. Inside the handle. When you need a bit, you just twist the black cap, pull the bit you need through the whole in the cap then lock it in place by twisting the cap back again.
Not like this: https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/61fruoFAqKL._AC_SL1500_.jpg
Stuart
Do any of the Retract-a-Bit screwdrivers look familiar?
https://retractabit.com/retract-a-bit-screwdrivers
Maybe a version of auto-loading screwdriver?
https://toolguyd.com/craftsman-auto-loading-ratcheting-screwdriver/
Joey
(re-sending my reply)
Yes, that is the word — “retractable”. Thanks Stuart.
The mechanism is similar just like this for example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCjUJBPwraE
But they look different. Mine is smaller and doesn’t have a pointed end, only the black cap thing.
Stuart
If your screwdriver is very similar and works in the same way , it could either be a variant such as from a partnered brand, or an older model.
Kris
Some unusual thoughts:
With the Picquic’s can you swap in doublesided bits from another brand? That could make a sixpac effectively a 12 in 1…
Also, I tried stuffing the 1″ bits into the Picquic and you can fit 3 in each slot (yup, they do rattle around), however, the bits are too short of the screwdriver end. You could conceivably put a small adapter on the end and have 3x the amount of bits… Not a fantastic idea if you’re wanting to access a specific bit size quickly, but great if you wanted to have a self contained all in one screwdriver.
And… if you merge the two ideas above, maybe you can stick Wera doublesided bits into the picquic? I imagine you’d have to be careful as some of them wouldn’t butt up against the backs of others very well if they’re finer tipped.
Anyone have the above items to try it and see if it’s effective?
Mason M
I know that down in Savannah, pretty much every HVAC guy has a Husky 6-in-1. Matter of fact, that was the first tool I ever bought for the purpose of working. Never been disappointed by it, though having moved on to being a mostly commercial tech at this point I now carry a Wiha 11-in-1 with the Torx bits swapped out for Klein’s Schraeder core bits.