Just in case you’re the last kid on your block to buy an impact driver (I’m kidding, of course), it looks like there’s a new Makita entry-level model at a decent price point.
The Makita XDT042 impact driver kit came out last year at $119, and then moved to $99. That’s a good price to pay for entry into a decent 18V cordless power tool platform.
I was recently checking on something, and Amazon was advertising that there’s a newer model – XDT111.
Taking a closer look, the Makita XDT111 impact driver kit looks very much the same. The included battery, charger, and carrying case look comparable to those bundled with the XDT111. Well, the charger looks different, but the model number’s the same (DC18RC).
On paper, the new XDT111 impact driver looks to be slightly improved in a few areas.
- More torque: 1460 in-lbs vs. 1420 in-lbs
- Shorter: 5-3/8″ long vs. 5-7/16″
- Faster: 0-2900 RPM and 0-3500 IPM vs. 0-2300 RPM and 0-3200 IPM
It’s a few ounces heavier: 3.9 lbs vs. 3.3 lbs. That’s the only potential negative.
Buy Now(via Amazon)
Let’s Think Things Through
Home Depot has also listed the XDT111, or at least there’s a trail linking to a taken-down listing. A cached page I found lists this impact driver at $99.
So… I’m guessing that, as with the XDT042, this Makita impact driver kit will also be available for $99. Amazon will likely drop the price as we get closer to the holiday shopping season.
Update: As of 11/1/2016, the price has dropped to $99 at Amazon. Thank you Dan for the heads-up!
My guess is that Makita saw the success of the XDT042 and decided to make a better model that’s also slightly cheaper to produce, in order to maximize the profits at $99. Why else would they come out with a second $99 impact driver kit only a year after the XDT042 was released? Thinking more about this, perhaps the tool borrows more closely from other current tools, and that’s how they’re reducing the costs.
Or maybe there’s another reason for the existence of the XDT111?
You know what? Forget all that.
Take a look at the Makita XDT11R kit, which retails for $176 at Amazon. It looks like this is the same exact impact that’s in the XDT111 kit. There’s also a bare tool.
Okay, so this certainly no longer looks like an entirely new impact driver. It looks like you’re getting a mainstream impact, but as part of a special 1-battery kit.
One thing confuses me. The bare tool is said to weigh 2.8 lbs with a compact battery pack. So the 3Ah battery adds a little more than a pound to the weight?
What does this mean for the XDT042? Will it be superseded by the XDT111? Or will the XDT042 remain the special holiday season model and the XDT111 a holiday season model and all-year mainstream model at $129 or so?
Something like a new $129 impact driver kit that goes on sale for $99 during the winter holiday season might seem small, but it can be hugely impactful for the tool market and for tool brands.
During holiday shopping seasons, nearly every single professional power tool brand competes in the $99 cordless drill and cordless impact driver kit space.
Makita has been offering single-battery models, as has Milwaukee. Bosch has a basic cordless drill that they bundle with 2 batteries, and Dewalt has done the same. Ridgid and Hitachi also have holiday promo offerings, and there are special Porter Cable bundles that dip below $99.
Understanding the context behind each of these offerings, such as whether a new was designed to be cheaper, or if it is taken from a brand’s regular tool lineup, is important.
Personally, I would rather buy a regular tool than one that has been cheapened in any way for holiday season masses. Perhaps “cheapened” isn’t the right word. Bosch’s promo drill, for example, is a compact less-frills model.
Dewalt has a new 20V Max impact driver kit, DCF885C1, and its price has already went from $139 to $130. They also have a new entry-level brushless drill, DCD777.
I think that the Dewalt DCF885C1, Makita XDT111, and Milwaukee 2656-21 (if available again) are great for users. When brands compete like this, we win.
I would be remiss if I didn’t point out that the Makita is the only one of the 3 that bundles their entry-level impact driver kit with a high capacity battery pack.
Buy Now(via Amazon)
I have the 42, it’s a great driver. I did notice that the housing on the 42 shares housing parts with a much older green Impact Driver they released (not sure of the model number), and the white driver (04RW). The specs were also the same as the 04RW, making it likely they shared a motor.
With the white tools discontinued, they could be moving to remove parts from their from their manufacturing and supply chain, and it’s always an opportunity to refresh the kit with a slightly newer model.
I find it interesting that this puts out more torque than my brushless Makita (LXDT08Z) impact. I’m surprised that there’s no gain in power, just efficiency by going to a brushless motor.
not that uncommon. it’s all about how you want to tune the brushless controller and function.
a brushed motor can put out just as much torque and RPM as any brushless.
The 27,000th impact driver released by tool companies so far. Lets see something actually interesting for the holidays Makita! You’re slacking!
Like the brushless 18V Sub Compact?
Hmmm. If I didn’t know better I’d say that the XDT111 is the same as the XDT11R with the exception of the included battery choice. The XDT11R comes bundled with 2 ea BL1820B batteries whereas the XDT111 comes with 1 ea BL1830. The 11R is an excellent tool so I would expect the 111 to be excellent as well. My 11R gets used hard almost everyday in the residential/light commercial repair and remodeling arena without the slightest problem. Even works on lug nuts as long as they aren’t over torqued.
I notice that for the Yellow tool owners – lots of folks (Acme, Amazon, ToolUp, International Tool are selling the DeWalt 20Vmax 2 battery DCF885M2 kit for $199 – saying that it is a special sale price.
That is a great kit, and I see it at an Amazon too:
$199 via Amazon
But… you can get the DCF886 or DCF887 for just a little more. Or the compact version of the DCF887 kit for a little less.
~$192 via Amazon
While it’s nice to get 4Ah batteries in the DCF885 kit, I’d rather use it with a smaller and lighter compact battery pack.
For buying into the system, I guess that DCF885M2 kit is hard to beat.
Sorry, ignore that big blue button if it’s intrusive.
Looks to be $99 on Amazon right now
Thank you, I have updated the price in the post to reflect this!