Leatherman is setting up a new store where you can buy and sell used multi-tools, called the Leatherman Exchange.
Details are still limited, but here are some takeaway points I found interesting:
“Sell and buy pre-loved Leatherman multi-tools backed by the brand that built them.”
Advertisement
Buyers will be able to browse through an “official collection of secondhand items.”
Sellers could “get up to a 110% store credit payout when they sell.”
Leatherman says they will “help connect” sellers of used Leatherman multi-tools with buyers “who’ll put it to work again.”
It sounds to me that you sell your used Leatherman multi-tool on their Exchange site, where the company “backs it,” presumably with continued warranty coverage, and you get a store credit when someone buys your old tool.
Personally, I’d be more interested in a Leatherman multi-tool trade-in program, rather than this consignment-like arrangement where you “list” a tool and can get a “store credit when you sell.”
Looking just a little deeper, apparently “recommerce” and “branded resale” is a thing.
Advertisement
What do you think about the new Leatherman Exchange used multi-tool market?
Robert
If leatherman really does back the used tools with a warranty I’d be interested as a buyer. Same tool at a cheaper price. But what’s in it for leatherman if they have a compelling price for resale? To not over commit in the warranty they will have to spend workers time to evaluate a lot of gadgets on a tool. Time is money. And it may cannibalize sales of new Leatherman.
Chris
Regarding cannibalizing of sales, of I were to guess, that is already happening and why they may be looking to do this. I have several Leatherman tools, but quite a few were handed down from my father. At this point, I would love to have a pair of the Raptors, but have no need for another standard style multi tool. And if I did, I would probably be looking second hand to begin with.
I think this is much like what has happened to ShopSmith (hey Stuart, that could make an interesting article). They are going out of business (again). Anyone that wants a ShopSmith, they are sitting around all over the place and going incredibly cheap at times second hand.
Everyone is making Leatherman style tools now. I appreciate them as an American company who revolutionized the concept. I will continue to support them as much as I can. But I just don’t think they will be able to hold their position going to far into the future without some business changes. And maybe, that is what they are thinking??
Scott K
I would love a Raptor but I absolutely cannot justify the cost for how little I’d likely use it. I saw a series of posts a few years ago about how good knockoffs on Amazon had gotten. I bought one for under $20 and it was terrible- sent it back right away.
Florian Placzek
I had one from work that was 20 years old sent it in. Got a new one no hassle.
D.B
The Market got to its max point.
First g: Swiss army
Second g: latherman.
Time for 3g.
It like they have no place to move.
JOHN PEARSON
I’ve got a few and I can’t afford anymore right now since I got hurt on work, but I’ve been a leather man man in my whole life
Scott K
I got this email, too. It’s an interesting concept. My initial thought was to wonder if they are having issues with warranty claims on counterfeit items. Some companies state they will confiscate counterfeit items if they’re sent in for repair. I thought this could be a way to clean up the second-hand marketplace and protect their brand.
It appears as though they are using a platform called Treet (https://www.treet.co/) that allows companies to setup different services: “Peer-to-Peer (Peer-to-Peer Resale), Trade-In (Take inventory back from customers), Off-Price (Sell excess inventory through resale), Returns (Reroute returns to be resold).”
The seller pays a 20% commission if they choose the cash option as opposed to the store credit.
Tim D.
20%?
I thought ebay was getting bad st 13%. I don’t think most sellers are going to opt for this marketplace with that kind of markup.
Jared
I assume this will be designed to incentivize sales of more Leatherman product, but I don’t quite understand how.
Perhaps the idea is that you list your Sidekick and upgrade to a Charge or Arc or something. Or maybe they’re talking about “up to” 110% trade in value based on what you paid back in the day and a particular tool being more valuable now.
I’m sure they’re getting a slice somehow, I’m just not sure where. Like do you have to send the tool into Leatherman to be verified and/or refurbished? It would seem ripe for abuse if they just coordinated buyers and sellers.
It all seems unnecessary, but I suppose someone might be tempted to try a good-condition tool at a slight discount – and then the seller in turn might want to swap to a different tool.
Scott K
I believe they are using a preexisting platform to manage the brunt of this. This is more like eBay and Leatherman helps with authentication through posted images. They send you a shipping label and you are responsible for packing and mailing. There’s a dispute resolution process if the quality is different or the tool isn’t authentic. I think the 110% is an incentive to use your sales credit to upgrade to a more expensive Leatherman. The alternative is to take the cash and likely pay a commission.
Stuart
Maybe if you opt for store credit, Leatherman pays a commission to the platform?
Scott K
I’d assume that that info is kept private. Companies are likely able to negotiate unique arrangements
Nathan
I’d certainly shop it if warranted and I might have 2 to sell. Should be interesting
Another Bob
Interesting concept. I don’t think I’ve ever heard of this before, and certainly not factory backed.
Is Leatherman innovating for the sake of innovation, or they jumping the shark? The whole Pacific Northwest knife Guild thing (The actual name escapes me) comes to mind. Steep competition from admittedly, decent quality, overseas manufacturers cutting into revenue streams? US based manufacturing pricing products out of the market? Are the copy cat, Chinese copies cutting into margins so much they’re trying to find other ways to stay relevant. Or are they just truly an innovative company and trying to bring new cool products/services to customers. The new custom sheaths and this new venture seems like things are getting shaken up a bit at Leatherman. Nothing wrong with pursuing new revenue dreams, just kinda out of the ordinary.
Magnus
My wave was ok but missing main blade and saw and the serrated was burnt, sent it in on warranty and got back a new wave +, incredible… the rest could be used to rebuild a old one and sell it for a good price, I was just hoping they would repair mine but upgrade of the pliers was a supper bonus
Max
Perhaps they are realizing how much they are pricing themselves put of the market are are trying something creative to get people to buy newer items?
I would never part with my Original, even though the tip broke off the knife blade (I ground a new one with my Worksharp), but I don’t know that I could afford to replace one of my newer ones if I lost it.
Prices have more than doubled in th3le past 5-10 years and that has to be shrinking their market share.
Eric W. Dick
I’ve had a Leatherman PST 1 now for over 30 yrs. Multiple sheath later, I broke the blade tip. They refused to fix it. The whole POINT of me buying it was that it would be fixed for life. Warranty or otherwise. I still carry it this very day. November 3, 2025.
Raul Gomez
I own 3 wave +, all used rough daily because I live on a large working ranch. I just sent 2 of them in for repair, so we will see how they treat me. Broken cutters from barbwire, pliers snapped leaving only 1 side, blades busted off and missing screw driver tips. Every blade dull, grinded on and used to hell and back. I jump start my tractor with the pliers by arc several times a week so they look like someone used them as welding rods. Store credit might be OK, but I just need them to stand behind repair or replacement.