Earlier today, Ben posted about Starrett’s Hidden Edge utility knife. Starrett’s Hidden Edge knife is a different take on safety knives than I’ve seen, and from what I can tell, it looks to be more practical to use, despite its larger size.
But if you’re looking for a safety utility knife in a standard form factor, there are many numerous models to choose from.
Advertisement
I’ve been using a Stanley safety utility knife for a couple of months now. I haven’t had any issues with regular utility knives or pocket knives, but decided to keep a Stanley safety knife near the front door for opening up boxes.
I also leave the safety knife there for my wife to use. I figure she’s more inclined to use a knife to open packages than scissors if it’s easy to close.
Spring-retraction safety knives self-retract when you release the blade extension button. Push the button when you want to use the knife, use it for a task, release the button, place the knife down or away, and you’re done. You don’t have to manually retract safety knife blades, making them somewhat safer to use than regular utility knives.
If you should accidentally drop a safety knife, the blade will retract safely within the knife’s housing before it hits the floor.
My safety knife came with a rounded-tip blade, and replacements are readily available. You can also buy these blades for your regular utility knives in most cases.
Advertisement
Blunted safety knife blades are useful for opening packages, as they are less likely to damage carton contents. With a regular utility knife, there’s a chance that you can score or damage the contents of a box if you extend the blade too far. This is more of an issue with folding utility knives, but can still happen with retractable ones.
Using safety knives is different, in that you MUST keep your finger on the retraction button. Otherwise, as soon as you release pressure, the blade pops back into the knife. This can make safety knives a hassle to use at times.
Starrett’s Hidden Edge knife works differently, and allows you to adjust and pre-set the blade extension length using a thumbwheel. When you hold or squeeze the two parts of the handle together, the knife deploys and stays deployed.
Regular safety knives work okay for what I use them for, but if I were required to use a safety knife in a workplace setting, I would definitely have my eye on the Starrett.
But also, if I were buying knives for others to use at a workplace setting, I would buy Stanley, Irwin, or Milwaukee safety knives, as they’re less expensive than the Starrett and easier to use without having to figure out the safety and adjustment mechanisms.
In addition to my Stanley, I also have a Milwaukee safety knife, but I haven’t a clue as to where I put it after I bought it. If I find it soon I’ll give it a quick review.
If you’re interested in a safety utility knife check your local home improvement store. In-store prices are occasionally better on these things.
Buy Now(Stanley via Amazon)
Buy Now(Other Styles via Amazon)
Buy Now(Stanley Blades via Amazon)
Brandon
If your work site requires a self retracting knife Tajima has the best one I’ve used hands down.
http://www.amazon.com/Tajima-VR-103-Self-Retracting-Piece-Utility/dp/B007JQ7O2U
Working at a BP refinery for a year we had to have self retracting knives. Building scaffold you often have to have every tool on a lanyard, so carrying a screw driver just to open your knife wasn’t going to happen. The stanley is alright, but changing the blade without a screw driver was a chore so it was rarely changed. A dull blade in a self retracting case is dangerous all on its own. The Tajima has a quick opening lever to allow fast blade changes. It’s also much more ergonomic.
It’s expensive, but if you have to use one daily, it’s worth the money. I’d almost consider making it my full time knife.
fred
For opening packaging – I have an older model of this NT Cutter
http://www.amazon.com/NT-Cutter-Safety-Remover-R-1200P/dp/B000TGCSXC/
but for some clamshell packaging I like to use a regular Stanley knife fitted with a hooked blade
Dave L.
I use these for clamshell packaging:
http://www.amazon.com/7-5-Trauma-Shears-Paramedic-Scissors/dp/B00I71EV2M/
Safe and handy for lots of things (though I ground off the clothing lift tip).
paul
OMG the almost exact knife we are issued at Home Depot… what a useless tool especially when cutting open bundles of dimensional lumber… what we say is that we carry the issued knife but all use the Milwaukee or Dewalt utility knives with the actual sharp points that do the work. if we get hurt “hurt” the blood will be on the POS HD safety knife not the Milwaukee of dewalt that actually works.
Brandon
I worked at the depot for a couple years after highschool and I remember those knives. They were different from the one above when I was there. They had the blade lever on the side and it only protruded 1/4″ or so. I had mine modified so the blade would go out further and stay out.
paul
“modified” I love it 🙂
Michael
Those knives and blades I’m sure have a lot of good uses but I find that for what I use them for, the Stanley retractable with the quick change blades work best
Joe
I really do not see the “safety” of it but more the convenience of it more.
But from personal experience, one utility knife is not enough if you are a serious worker lol
Rick
To not damage carton contents, just pinch the blade ~1/8″ from the point. The only gimmick I like on utility knives is the regular retracting model with a screw to open ‘er up and a hook blade when needed. Anything else is too much…